Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2529 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Are Prophets Infallible at Every Stage of Their Lives?

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2529

I’m sorry to trouble you. I had a discussion with Ustad Delgosha about Surah al-Qasas, verse 15, and Surah al-A‘raf, verse 150, and the question of whether prophets can make mistakes. He says, on the basis of these verses, that prophets are not infallible at every stage of their lives and may err; they are infallible only in receiving and conveying revelation. I’m sending this to you and would be grateful for your guidance.

[Forwarded from Du'a]

Dear Ustad, as I understood the exegesis of this verse, the incident took place when Moses was living in Pharaoh’s household, and seems to belong to the period before his prophethood.

In the exchange between Moses and Pharaoh, Pharaoh says, “You are the one who did that”—meaning the killing—and accuses him of repaying his kindness and favors with ingratitude. Moses replies, “If I did it, I did so when I was among the misguided.”

Since Moses had left Pharaoh’s household by the time he went to meet Pharaoh as a prophet, with a miracle, this killing must have taken place before he reached maturity, while he was living in Pharaoh’s household. On the day the incident occurred, he had gone out of Pharaoh’s palace.

[Forwarded from Reflection on the Qur’an]

A Moment of Reflection (153)

ولما رجع موسى إلى قومه غضبان أسفا قال بئسما خلفتمونی من بعدی ۖ أعجلتم أمر ربکم ۖ وألقى الألواح وأخذ برأس أخیه یجره إلیه ۚ قال ابن أم إن القوم استضعفونی وکادوا یقتلوننی فلا تشمت بی الأعداء ولا تجعلنی مع القوم الظالمین [اعراف/150]

“When Moses returned to his people, angry and grieving, he said, ‘What a terrible way you have acted in my absence! Were you impatient for your Lord’s command?’ He cast down the tablets, seized his brother by the head and pulled him towards himself. (His brother Aaron) said, ‘Son of my mother! The people overpowered me, and almost killed me. So do not let my enemies gloat over me, and do not count me among the wrongdoing people (the polytheists).’”

Moses was mistaken in blaming Aaron. (Both the one at fault and the one bringing the complaint are prophets.) This shows that prophets are not free from every kind of mistake; rather, they are infallible with regard to errors in conveying revelation and teaching the Sharia. Moreover, this verse shows that Moses had not known what had happened beforehand. Prophets do not know everything; they know what they need to know.

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The great prophets are infallible in conveying their message. Before receiving their mission, however, they may make mistakes, which are remedied through repentance and turning back to God. Any possible lapses during their mission relate to their spiritual rank; they do not diminish their standing. Rather, through repentance, their rank is raised.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Certainly, the great prophets are protected from error in conveying their message! The period before a prophet’s mission should not be treated as the same as the period during it. The prophets were certainly protected from the stain of idolatry before their missions, though they could make mistakes, which they followed with repentance and turning back to God.

But the mistakes prophets made during their missions—mistakes that did not involve idolatry, as well as sins—relate to their rank and station. Only the most exalted among them are protected from every kind of error!

The episode in which Moses confronted Aaron, and the accounts of David and Jonah (peace be upon them), concern things that would have been better left undone. Had they not done them, their rank would have risen; doing them did not entail any reduction in their station. Rather, when they recognized their mistakes and turned to God in earnest repentance, their station changed and they rose to higher ranks.

Thus, both the actions that were better done than left undone, and those that were better left undone than done, could lead to an elevation in their rank, provided they chose what was better—whether by acting or refraining.

الله یعلم

I’m sorry to trouble you.

Dear teacher, I had a discussion with Mr. Delgosha about verse 15 of Surah al-Qasas and verse 150 of Surah al-A‘raf, concerning whether prophets make mistakes. He says, on the basis of this verse, that prophets are not protected from error at every stage of their lives and do make mistakes; they are protected only in receiving and conveying revelation. I’m sending the discussion to you. I would be grateful for your guidance.

[Forwarded from دعا]

Dear teacher, as I understand the interpretation of this verse, the incident took place when Moses was in Pharaoh’s household and therefore probably belongs to the period before his prophethood.

In the exchange between Moses and Pharaoh, Pharaoh says, “You are the one who did that”—meaning the killing—and then reproaches him for having denied the favors and kindness Pharaoh had shown him. Moses replies, “If I did that, I did it when I was among the misguided.”

Moses left Pharaoh’s household and later went to meet Pharaoh as a prophet, with a miracle. So this killing dates to the period before his prophethood, when he was still a child, while living in Pharaoh’s household. The day the incident took place, he had gone out of Pharaoh’s palace.

[Forwarded from Reflection on the Qur’an]

A moment of reflection (153)

ولما رجع موسى إلى قومه غضبان أسفا قال بئسما خلفتمونی من بعدی ۖ أعجلتم أمر ربکم ۖ وألقى الألواح وأخذ برأس أخیه یجره إلیه ۚ قال ابن أم إن القوم استضعفونی وکادوا یقتلوننی فلا تشمت بی الأعداء ولا تجعلنی مع القوم الظالمین [اعراف/150]

When Moses returned to his people, angry and grieved, he said, “What a bad successor you have been in my absence! Did you hurry ahead of your Lord’s command?” He cast down the tablets, took his brother by the head, and pulled him towards himself. Aaron said, “Son of my mother, the people overpowered me, and they were about to kill me. Do not let my enemies gloat over me, and do not count me among the wrongdoing people—the idolaters.”

Moses was mistaken in holding Aaron responsible (both the one at fault and the one making the accusation were prophets). This shows that prophets are not free from every kind of mistake; rather, they are protected from error in conveying revelation and teaching the religious law. This verse also shows that Moses had not known about the matter beforehand. Prophets, then, do not know everything; they know what they need to know.

#Answer 2529

Certainly, the great prophets are protected from error in conveying their message! The period before a prophet’s mission should not be treated as the same as the period during it. The prophets were certainly protected from the stain of idolatry before their missions, though they could make mistakes, which they followed with repentance and turning back to God.

But the mistakes prophets made during their missions—mistakes that did not involve idolatry, as well as sins—relate to their rank and station. Only the most exalted among them are protected from every kind of error!

The episode in which Moses confronted Aaron, and the accounts of David and Jonah (peace be upon them), concern things that would have been better left undone. Had they not done them, their rank would have risen; doing them did not entail any reduction in their station. Rather, when they recognized their mistakes and turned to God in earnest repentance, their station changed and they rose to higher ranks.

Thus, both the actions that were better done than left undone, and those that were better left undone than done, could lead to an elevation in their rank, provided they chose what was better—whether by acting or refraining.

الله یعلم

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022