Greetings, Ustad Saei. Some people believe that all the Divine Attributes are one and incapable of multiplicity in the Sacred Essence—for example, the Merciful = the Compeller = the All-Merciful = the Supremely Great = the Loving, and so on. They say that when these attributes enter the realm of Lahut, they become multiple. How is that possible? They explain it this way: it is like white light shining through a prism. The light is one, but when it passes through the prism, yellow, red, violet, and other colors emerge. So, they conclude, all the attributes are one in the Essence, because if there were multiplicity, God’s Essence would be composite rather than immaterial. The attributes are therefore one in the Essence; when they enter a lower realm, such as the realm of Lahut, that realm acts like a prism and the attributes become multiple. Do you agree with this theory?
Are the Divine Attributes One in the Essence and Multiple in the Realm of Lahut?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
If the oneness of the Divine Attributes in the Essence means setting an attribute apart from the Essence, that is shirk. God’s Most Beautiful Names unfold from unity into multiplicity, while the Essence of the Real is too exalted to be described by any attribute. Takbīr means denying every attribute that would describe the Essence of the Real.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterEven if we regard God’s attribute as one—reducing all the different attributes to a single attribute—the abscess of shirk still bursts open. Why?
Because we set that single attribute over against the Essence. In other words, God forbid, we conceive of the infinite, eternal, unique, incomparable Being as composed of essence and attribute, thereby entering the realm of associating partners with God. That is, even when all the attributes are brought into unity, they still stand in the way of the Unity and Oneness of the Most Exalted Creator in relation to the Essence. This is the secret behind the Master’s saying:
کمال الإخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه لشهاده کل صفه أنها غیر الموصوف و شهاده کل موصوف أنه غیر الصفه فمن ...
The secret lies in this subtle point: what admits of multiplicity is God’s Most Beautiful Names. They have journeyed from unity to multiplicity; the one light has branched into different lights. The Divine Essence is magnified through the takbir, which in reality negates every kind of attribute (الله الکبر = God is greater than can be described). In proclaiming God’s greatness, we regard the Divine Essence as too exalted to be described by any attribute. Thus, no attribute can be found that we might regard as an attribute of the Essence and use to describe the Divine Essence. The Divine Essence has no need of description, nor of becoming known or renowned.