Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1223 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

Are the Stories about Sayyid Bahr al-Ulum in *Karamat al-Husayniyya* Authentic?

Primary reference: See the answer text 30 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1223

سلام علیکم, esteemed teacher.

In کرامات الحسینیه, vol. 2, p. 216, it is related that one day during ‘Ashura, Sayyid Bahr al-Ulum went with a group of students from Karbala to welcome the Tuwairij chest-beating procession. Suddenly, the students saw that the late Sayyid Bahr al-Ulum, despite his great stature and eminent scholarly rank, had set aside his turban and cloak, bared his chest like the other mourners, and thrown himself among them, beating his head and chest.

The students who had come with him tried everything they could to restrain such an outpouring of pure emotion, but to no avail. At last, some of them formed a ring around Sayyid Bahr al-Ulum to protect him from being trampled or hurt. When the chest-beating had ended, some of his close companions asked him, “How did it happen that you were swept up in the procession and became so deeply absorbed in mourning?”

The Sayyid replied, “When I reached the procession, I saw حضرت بقیه الله علیه السلام among the mourners, bareheaded and barefoot, beating his head and chest and weeping. I could not bear it; I lost all awareness of myself and joined him in beating my chest.”

Is this account mistaken? Or was Sayyid Bahr al-Ulum mistaken about what he saw?

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Relying on stories such as those found in *Karamat al-Husayniyya* as evidence about the conduct of the Infallibles and great religious figures is problematic. Such accounts may have been fabricated to introduce religious innovations or deceive people, and may not meet the standards of Islamic law and hadith scholarship. Although Shi'a Muslims are highly rigorous when deriving religious rulings, they cannot rely on stories lacking a credible chain of transmission when assessing the conduct of the Infallibles.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

O Abu Abdillah! Would that I could burn with grief for you, be reduced to ashes, and become dust beneath the feet of those who love you!

Wilayah is the pillar of Islam, and its importance surpasses that of prayer, almsgiving, fasting and pilgrimage. Yet when deriving rulings on prayer and fasting, Shi‘a scholars are so scrupulous that they reject any hadith whose chain of transmission is not sound, and examine the chain and text of a hadith with painstaking care. How, then, could they rely on a story concerning the master key to the divine rulings, and, when it comes to the conduct and tradition of God’s vicegerent, set aside the Qur’an and the pure hadiths and settle for a tale?

When recounting certain stories, people sometimes invoke the names of revered figures to make the story seem credible. Their popularity can lead others to suspend all thought and reflection about what is being reported. The scheme of inventing stories to introduce innovations, deceive and mislead has been current since the earliest days of Islam.

The story in question raises many questions.

How did the scholar know the Imam? If he had seen him, why did he make it public? Do we not have a hadith in which the Imam says that those who claim to have seen him should be denied? Do we not know that, during the Imam’s occultation, any claim to be his agent or special deputy is rejected? Do we not know that the actions of an infallible are among the sources of religious authority? Did the Imam, through his own action, tacitly endorse a ruling—and that, through someone who could not be his deputy? The story mentions bare feet and an uncovered head, not a naked body, and so on.

Nudity has nothing to do with the anguish and grief of mourning for the Imam al-Husayn عليه السلام! How many devotees at his threshold have been consumed by love, their fervour and grief renowned and envied by his admirers, yet have never lost even an iota of their composure in mourning for him!

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022