Excuse me, Ustad. In the tawqīʿ you mentioned, it says: الا فمن ادعی المشاهده قبل.... فهو کذاب مفتر..
Is this claim of having seen the Imam intended specifically for those who have claimed special deputyship? Would those who have seen the Imam but made no claim whatsoever to special deputyship also, in some way, fall under this part of the tawqīʿ? Thank you.
Are those who have seen the Imam but make no claim to deputyship also included under «فهو کذاب مفتر»?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A claim to having seen the Imam—or to being his deputy—even without claiming special deputyship, falls under «فهو کذاب مفتر». If there were an exception, anyone could simply declare themselves exempt. The discipline of rijāl is essential for recognizing the Imam and distinguishing truth from falsehood, because without it, one cannot recognize others—or even know God.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThis claim applies to everyone, because if there were an exception, everyone would declare themselves exempt!
If someone were to meet the Imam, surely that encounter would not provide grounds for making any claim. The Imam’s words are historical evidence, and they have not been superseded. Anyone who claims that the Imam imparts knowledge to them is challenging the Imam’s proofs and principles, and treating them as null and void.
The knowledge of rijāl is not impossible to acquire, and its difficulty is no reason for certain claims to arise. If we were certain that someone had met the Imam, surely the Imam could easily have instilled the knowledge of rijāl in that person’s heart as well, providing decisive proof for such claims!
Whoever is not versed in rijāl will not be versed in the Imam either. Whoever does not learn the alphabet will be unable to read words and sentences. Whoever does not know himself will be incapable of knowing others. Whoever cannot read a small book will be even less capable of reading a great one. If someone cannot come to know ordinary people, how will they know the Gate of God?