Professor, given that we know people who are devout and spiritually sensitive can be in contact with the infallible Imam (AS)—something that has happened repeatedly, and many people have been and are in contact with the Imam of the Age—perhaps we have not recognised them until now and never will. Do these people need human disciplines such as the science of rijāl to acquire religious knowledge, or do they receive their guidance directly from the Imam? What about people who have received certain gifts through acts of devotion? Are they, too, independent of this science? I am not asking about ordinary people, who certainly need such disciplines. Thank you.
Do People Who Claim to Be in Contact with the Imam of the Age (AJ) Need the Science of Rijāl?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
If a claim of contact with the Imam of the Age (AJ) is genuine, it must be confirmed directly by the Imam himself. In the era of the Greater Occultation, claims of seeing him or serving as his deputy are false and fabricated. The science of rijāl is essential for distinguishing truth from falsehood and assessing the credibility of such claims, since we have no choice but to rely on what is certain.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIf someone claims to be in direct contact with an Infallible, the authenticity of that contact must be established directly by the Imam himself; otherwise, any such claim is false.
Even if, hypothetically, the contact were genuine, its authority could be accepted only by the person concerned. For the claimant would have to convince others that the claim was true, and that could be done only through rational and transmitted proofs. In fact, this underscores the importance of the science of narrator criticism: we must turn to established certainties and accepted principles before accepting certain claims.
One way to substantiate such a claim would be for the Infallible Imam to provide signs, portents and miracles as proof that the claimant represents him. But if that were to happen, there would be no need for a representative, since the Imam himself could appear directly.
The present age is one of awakening, spiritual discipline and trial. One of its lessons is the exercise of ijtihad and the derivation of divine rulings from the Qur’an and the Sunnah of the Messenger and the divinely guided leaders. This will continue until the appearance of the Imam.
Guidance and a connection with the Imam may be granted to anyone.
In the Imam’s letter to his final envoy, every possibility of claiming deputyship during the Greater Occultation is closed off. Anyone who makes such a claim is a liar and has slandered God’s guardian.
The science of narrator criticism was practised during the time of the Messenger of God (peace be upon him) and each of the Imams, under its own particular conditions. This was because narrators transmitted hadith, and their reliability was the criterion for accepting their reports; the lack of reliability of some narrators was grounds for disregarding them.
و أخبرنا جماعه عن أبی جعفر محمد بن علی بن الحسین بن بابویه قال حدثنی أبو محمد الحسن بن أحمد المکتب قال کنت بمدینه السلام فی السنه التی توفی فیها الشیخ أبو الحسن علی بن محمد السمری قدس سره فحضرته قبل وفاته بأیام فأخرج إلى الناس توقیعا نسخته:
یا علی بن محمد السمری أعظم الله أجر إخوانک فیک فإنک میت ما بینک و بین سته أیام فاجمع أمرک و لا توص إلى أحد فیقوم مقامک بعد وفاتک فقد وقعت الغیبه التامه فلا ظهور إلا بعد إذن الله تعالى ذکره و ذلک بعد طول الأمد و قسوه القلوب و امتلاء الأرض جورا و سیأتی شیعتی «1» من یدعی المشاهده [ألا فمن ادعى المشاهده] «2» قبل خروج السفیانی و الصیحه فهو کذاب مفتر و لا حول و لا قوه إلا بالله العلی العظیم قال فنسخنا هذا التوقیع و خرجنا من عنده فلما کان الیوم السادس عدنا إلیه و هو یجود بنفسه فقیل له من وصیک من بعدک فقال لله أمر هو بالغه و قضى فهذا آخر کلام سمع منه رضی الله عنه و أرضاه
الغیبه (للطوسی)/ کتاب الغیبه للحجه، النص، ص: 395