Researchers have recently been exploring the theory that, if we removed genes associated with bad behaviour and replaced them with genes linked to good behaviour (at least those that have been identified), we could create a being with entirely good qualities. Of course, this is only theoretical and at the laboratory stage. According to them, we have genes for evil and bad traits—some people have more, others less. But this raises a question: can evil traits actually be part of human nature and innate disposition, or are human beings pure by nature, with evil arising from other causes? For example, you said that ignorance is created by God. Can ignorance be an inherent, innate quality in a person from birth? In other words, can someone be born with a bad trait?
Can Evil Traits Be Part of Human Nature and Innate Disposition?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Every human being’s innate nature is pure. Ignorance is not inherent; it arises later, and its point of entry goes back to a realm before earthly life. A person’s genes are one example of what belongs to their nature, but altering them does not change the fundamental reality, because the human spirit—the inner self—affects the outward self.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWe do not choose our bodies; rather, a body suited to our spirit is chosen for us!
A pure spirit is suited to a pure body, and a corrupt spirit to a corrupt body. Each spirit is paired with a body of corresponding rank, in keeping with its own degree.
A person’s genes are a reflection of that person’s essence; tampering with them can in no way alter the underlying reality.
Even genes possess a particular spirituality: their inner nature influences their outward form.
Every particle, including a person’s genes, is made up of different layers of life, only one of which is material.
A wolf is a wolf in any den—whether in a palace, a salt marsh, or a flower garden. So what matters is a person’s spirit: even if their outward structure changes, their inner nature remains the same.
If a person’s genes change, such changes will ultimately lead to a state in which they attract a spirit suited to that particular state.
But here is the question:
Can ignorance be an innate, inborn trait in a person from birth? In other words, can someone be born with a bad characteristic?
Everyone’s innate nature is pure; there is no disagreement about that. Ignorance, too, is not intrinsic to human beings, since it comes upon them. But where it takes hold goes back to before the earthly realm.
﴿الأعراف : 101 تلک القرى نقص علیک من أنبائها و لقد جاءتهم رسلهم بالبینات فما کانوا لیؤمنوا بما کذبوا من قبل کذلک یطبع الله على قلوب الکافرین﴾
These are the towns, some of whose stories We recount to you. Their messengers came to them with clear proofs, but they would not believe in what they had previously rejected. Thus does God seal the hearts of the disbelievers.
﴿یونس : 74 ثم بعثنا من بعده رسلا إلى قومهم فجاؤهم بالبینات فما کانوا لیؤمنوا بما کذبوا به من قبل کذلک نطبع على قلوب المعتدین﴾
Then, after him, We sent messengers to their people. They came to them with clear proofs, but they would not believe in what they had previously rejected. Thus do We seal the hearts of those who transgress, so that they cannot understand.