Question 335-1:
As you know, there are times when Hajj is no longer obligatory for someone who is able to perform it—for example, when there is no security. Can disavowal and cursing also be suspended, as Hajj can, if they would cause harm?
Master Ali Saei’s answer to question number [as stated]: It is clear that, under the present circumstances, publicly cursing those who deserve to be cursed has repercussions. The principles of disavowal and allegiance, however, remain in place; it is the manner of expressing them that varies according to the circumstances!
Can Public Disavowal and Cursing Be Suspended?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The principles of disavowal and allegiance remain in place, but how they are expressed depends on the circumstances and their possible consequences. When public cursing may have repercussions, the way it is expressed should be adapted to the circumstances.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterQuestion 335-1:
As you know, Hajj may at times no longer be obligatory for someone who is able to perform it—for example, when security is lacking. Can disavowal and cursing likewise be suspended, as Hajj can, if they would cause harm?
Master Ali Saei’s answer to the question: It is clear that, under the present circumstances, publicly cursing those who deserve to be cursed has consequences. But the principle of disavowal and allegiance remains in place; it is the way they are expressed that varies according to the circumstances.