Peace be upon you. #Question 1538
⏪الإمام علی علیه السلام :إن العقل فی القلب
Imam al-Sadiq (peace be upon him): The seat of intellect is the heart.
. الأدب المفرد : 166 / 547 عن عیاض بن خلیفه ، شرح نهج البلاغه : 20 / 256 / 10 .
⏪ الإمام الصادق علیه السلام :العقل مسکنه فی القلب
. الکافی: 8/190/218 ، علل الشرایع: 107/3 کلاهما عن أبی جمیله عمن ذکره عن الإمام الباقر علیه السلام .
عنه علیه السلام :القلب وهو أمیر الجوارح الذی به تعقل وتفهم وتصدر عن أمره ورأیه
Imam Ali (peace be upon him): The heart is the ruler of the bodily faculties; through it, one reasons and understands, and they act in accordance with its command and judgment.
. الفقیه : 2 / 627 / 3215 .
⁉ Given the hadiths above, which state that the seat of intellect is the heart, and the third hadith, which describes choice as belonging to the heart, can we call the heart the faculty of choice?
#Answer 1538
The heart is, in effect, the workplace of the intellect. In other words, it is the intellect’s center of learning and action. Its defining quality is that it is alive. Put another way, the heart is a conscious, intelligent system, and the intellect is its user. But how choice takes place, and through which bodily or inward faculties, requires careful consideration. The heart certainly plays a fundamental role in choice. Yet the human being’s true self is not the heart: the heart is one of the human being’s inward faculties. Choice therefore belongs, without doubt, to the human being—to the human being’s true self, or “I”—which is veiled beneath the bodily and inward faculties.
The human being has a heart, but also has an independent reality apart from the heart. Through this reality, the human being directs the heart and either accepts the intellect or turns away from it!
Q: 37 Truly in this is a reminder for whoever has a heart, or listens attentively while present.
In view of the hadiths, the heart is a created entity brought into being for the human being: «خلق قلوبهم»
حدثنا محمد بن عیسى عن أبی الحجاج قال: قال لی أبو جعفر ع یا أبا الحجاج إن الله خلق محمدا و آل محمد من طینه علیین و خلق قلوبهم من طینه فوق ذلک و خلق شیعتنا من طینه دون علیین و خلق قلوبهم من طینه علیین فقلوب شیعتنا من أبدان آل محمد و إن الله خلق عدو آل محمد من طین سجین و خلق قلوبهم من طین أخبث من ذلک و خلق شیعتهم من طین دون طین سجین و خلق قلوبهم من طین سجین فقلوبهم من أبدان أولئک و کل قلب یحن إلى بدنه.
بصائر الدرجات فی فضائل آل محمد صلى الله علیهم، ج1، ص: 14