⏪⁉ Please critique the text above:
A very brief reflection on the Hadith of the Armies of Intellect and Ignorance:
This is Hadith 14 in *Usul al-Kafi*. It states explicitly that Intellect and Ignorance each have 75 troops, yet in the end 78 troops are listed for each. Of course, affliction is mentioned twice as a troop of Ignorance: once in contrast to well-being, and again in contrast to health.
But whether affliction should be considered a troop of Ignorance is a serious matter for reflection, since affliction is so closely associated with the righteous that it has been said: “البلاء للولاء”. We also have many narrations stating that being a Shi‘i goes hand in hand with great hardship and suffering. And, of course, the Qur’an presents the Prophet Ayyub as a model of patience in the face of affliction...
This hadith also counts poverty among the troops of Ignorance, which conflicts with the well-known Prophetic saying, “الفقر فخری”. Even if this hadith has a weakness in its chain of transmission, the Prophet’s poverty is an established fact in the history of Islam, and is also referred to in the Qur’an (al-Ahzab 33:28).
More important than all of this, however, is that knowledge is counted among the troops of Intellect, and ignorance among the troops of Ignorance!
The contrast between knowledge and ignorance, together with the statement at the end of the narration that all the troops of Intellect are gathered in the Prophet and the Prophet’s successor, shows that knowledge here is not absolute. Absolute knowledge belongs only to God, and, as the Qur’an attests, even the Noble Prophet did not know everything there was to know (al-Nazi‘at 79:43).
Accordingly, the forgetfulness listed in this hadith among the troops of Ignorance must be understood as relative and limited forgetfulness, not absolute forgetfulness; in this way, it does not conflict with the very reliable hadith, “سهو النبی”. Even if there were a conflict, however, this interpretation could not withstand that hadith, since, quite apart from the fact that the hadith of “سهو النبی” has a very strong chain of transmission, it is also supported by the Qur’an’s explicit statements and allusions. والله یعلم