Do differences in the capacity of bodily members to participate in sin go back to the Covenant of Alast and the choices made there, or is there another explanation? For example, what sin could an organ like the appendix participate in, when an organ like the tongue is constantly at risk of being used in sin?
We also see differences among people in their tendency to participate in sin. For instance, someone may be more prone to backbiting because, say, they have inherited a tendency to talk a lot, which can lead them into sin. Another person may simply have no interest in talking and be an introvert, and so be less prone to backbiting.
Is this a sound comparison?
Do Differences in the Capacity of Bodily Members to Sin Go Back to the Covenant of Alast?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The makeup of our earthly bodies corresponds to our spiritual nature, and every particle of the body—even its organs—has awareness and the capacity to make decisions. Created beings took part in various covenants in different realms, and their histories affect their conduct and actions in this world. These differences go back to the Covenant of Alast and the choices made there.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe makeup of our earthly bodies is in keeping with the spiritual nature of our souls. Every particle in the universe—including the particles that make up our bodies—possesses awareness, vitality, and feeling. Accordingly, the organs formed from these particles have a new identity, a spirit and awareness of their own, and, at their own level, the capacity to make decisions and cooperate!
All the creatures of the universe (its particles) took part in different covenants in various realms, and their past has a bearing on their conduct, deeds, and decisions in this world!
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال سمعته یقول إن الله خلقنا من نور عظمته ثم صور خلقنا من طینه مخزونه مکنونه من تحت العرش فأسکن ذلک النور فیه فکنا نحن خلقا و بشرا نورانیین لم یجعل لأحد فی مثل الذی خلقنا منه نصیبا و خلق أرواح شیعتنا من طینتنا و أبدانهم من طینه مخزونه مکنونه أسفل من ذلک الطینه و لم یجعل الله لأحد فی مثل الذی خلقهم منه نصیبا إلا للأنبیاء و لذلک صرنا نحن و هم الناس و صار سائر الناس همجا- للنار و إلى النار.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج1، ص: 389
جابر قال: قال أبو جعفر علیه السلام:
المؤمن أخو المؤمن لأبیه و أمه، و ذلک أن الله خلق المؤمن من طینه جنان السماوات و أجرى فی صورهم من ریح روحه فلذلک هم إخوه لأب و أم. «4»
الأصول السته عشر (ط - دار الحدیث)، ص: 219