Question 444
Master Ali Saei’s answer to question number 444
🍀🔅🌟سلام علیکم🌟🔅🍀
🔆🔅🌱If the created world were broken down, it would yield not four elements but more than a hundred—or hundreds, even thousands upon thousands. Soil itself is made up of many different elements, as are fire, air and water, each a combination of multiple elements. And every individual element, in turn, is made up of different particles.
🔆🔅🌱Ascribing divine consciousness to the four elements in question is vague and ambiguous. If the claim is that divine consciousness exists within these elements, that amounts to a form of blasphemy, since consciousness is a quality of created beings, not of the Creator, the All-Knowing.
🔆🔅🌱There is no rational, textual, historical or empirical evidence that prayers are answered where the four elements come together! Besides, is the human body not made of clay—a clay that contains soil, water, gas and air? To sanctify a candle has no basis and could even lead to candle worship. The sun is far more mysterious than a candle flame, as are the vast galaxies and other such things, yet all of them are God’s creations.
🔆🔅🌱It is incorrect to call candle wax soil. The term “soil” is used for particular elements in specific combinations; in fact, soils are mixtures of mineral and organic matter...
🔆🔅🌱Candle smoke is not wind; it is a mixture of different elements released as the candle burns. Wind is moving air!
🔆🔅🌱Melted wax is not water; it is liquid wax. Water is what gives life and tastes refreshing to drink. Melted wax cannot be drunk.
🔆🔅🌱The claim that “looking at a burning candle connects one to divine consciousness” is an impertinence towards God, who has no equal. The merciful God is the creator of consciousness. Thought, reflection, reason and the like are qualities of created beings, signs of their limitations, and means of attaining knowledge, whereas the incomparable God is All-Knowing. Consciousness is a means of reaching the light of knowledge, and points to the ignorance of the one who seeks knowledge through it.
🔆🔅🌱A candle flame cannot raise itself up or keep itself alight; in the end, it is extinguished in utter abasement. How could it be a messenger for prayers? For prayers to rise, faith and righteous deeds are needed; special devotions give the wings of prayer greater reach.
🔆🔅🌱Blowing out a candle is a childish act and...
🔆🔅🌱To dress polytheistic ideas up as mystical feelings and states is the height of ineptitude.
Do the Four Elements—Water, Earth, Fire, and Air—Possess Divine Consciousness?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The four elements—water, earth, fire, and air—do not possess divine consciousness, and attributing consciousness to them is an act of disbelief. There is no rational, scriptural, or empirical basis for prayers being answered where these elements converge. Venerating a candle can also lead to idolatry: a candle flame cannot sustain itself and will eventually go out, whereas prayer requires faith and righteous deeds.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIf the created world were divided up, it would not yield four elements but more than a hundred—or hundreds, or even thousands upon thousands. Earth itself is made up of many elements, as are fire, air and water, each a combination of multiple elements. And each element, in turn, is made up of different particles.
The claim that the four elements in question possess divine consciousness is vague and unclear. If it means that divine consciousness exists within the soul of these elements, then it is a kind of blasphemy, since consciousness is a characteristic of created beings, not of the Creator, the All-Knowing.
There is no rational, scriptural, historical or empirical evidence that prayers are answered where the four elements come together! Besides, is the human body not made of clay—a clay containing earth, water, gas and air? Ascribing sanctity to a candle has no basis and may well lead to candle worship. The sun is far more mysterious than a candle’s flame, as are the vast galaxies and so on, even though all of them are God’s creatures and creations.
It is inaccurate to call candle wax earth. The term “earth” is applied to certain elements in particular combinations; in fact, soils are mixtures of mineral and organic matter…
Candle smoke is not air but a combination of different elements released as the candle burns. Wind is moving air!
Melted wax is not water; it is liquid wax. Water is what gives life and is pleasant to drink. Melted wax cannot be drunk.
The statement that “gazing at a burning candle brings one into connection with divine consciousness” is an audacious affront to the incomparable God. The merciful God is the creator of consciousness. Thought, reflection, reason and the like are characteristics of created beings and signs of their imperfection; they are tools for attaining knowledge. The peerless God, by contrast, is All-Knowing. Consciousness is a means of reaching the light of knowledge, and it points to the ignorance of the conscious being, who seeks knowledge through consciousness.
A candle flame cannot raise itself up or keep itself alight; in the end, it is extinguished in utter abasement. How, then, could it be a messenger carrying prayers? For prayer to ascend requires faith and righteous deeds; through special supplications, its wings are spread wider.
Blowing out a candle is a childish act, and so on…
To dress polytheistic ideas in the language of mystical feeling is the height of ineptitude.