Does «و اتممناها بعشر» indicate a change to God’s promise, or the fulfilment of that promise, as in «والله متم نوره»?
When God says, «ادعونی استجب لکم», and we pray but our prayer is not answered, does that mean God has changed His mind about His promise? Or is the truth that we have not actually managed to offer a prayer that rises to Him? For if someone does offer such a prayer, would God not answer it?
In the hadith you quoted from Imam al-Jawad (peace be upon him), the Sufyani and the Imam of the Age (peace be upon him) are mentioned. What connection is there between the Imam of the Age’s birth and very existence, and the Sufyani?
(The connection is only between the Imam’s appearance and the Sufyani. In other sources, the Sufyani is mentioned as one of the signs of the Imam of the Age’s appearance, and the Imam’s interlocutor was very likely aware of this. Imam al-Jawad (peace be upon him) says: “The Qa’im (peace be upon him) is part of the promise; there is no doubt about it.” In other words, there is no doubt that he will appear, because this is a promise.
So the Imam’s appearance is connected with the Sufyani.)
Can you show us a hadith that connects the Sufyani’s uprising with a reality other than the appearance of the Imam of the Age (may God hasten his reappearance)?
—Another question that arises here is: how are we to interpret the following verses?
«و لقد کتبنا فی الزبور من بعد الذکر ان الارض یرثها عبادی الصالحون»
«یریدون لیطفئوا نور الله بافواههم والله متم لنوره و لو کره الکافرون»
«قل ارایتم ان اصبح ماءوکم غورا فمن یاتیکم بما معین»
And so on.
Have God’s righteous servants inherited the earth?
Do these verses not indicate that the appearance is a promise?
#Response 3008
«و اتممناها بعشر» does not indicate a change to the promise; rather, it refers to its completion. The promise was fulfilled and completed with ten days.
The fulfilment of God’s promise, and its completion, accord with the divine will—not necessarily with our interpretations and understanding.
A prayer going unanswered, despite God’s promise in the verse «ادعونی استجب لکم», does not indicate that God has changed His mind. Rather, it shows that the conditions for the prayer to be answered have not been met.
In the words of Imam al-Jawad (peace be upon him): «... إن القائم من المیعاد و الله لا یخلف المیعاد»
In this passage, the Imam merely refers to the Qa’im (may God’s blessings be upon him). He says nothing about the details of his appearance, how it will take place, or the conditions under which God’s promise will be fulfilled.
The appearance of the Imam of the Age (peace be upon him) will accord with the divine will, not human speculation. How God’s promise will be fulfilled in the matter of the appearance is unseen; only He knows. Whether it is with the Sufyani or without him, with 313 people or without them, with the community or without it, with human beings or with others.
Even now, the Imam of the Age (peace be upon him) is the inheritor of the earth and God’s vicegerent. In due time, by God’s permission and power, he will cleanse the earth of the stain of polytheism, oppression and corruption. How God’s certain promise is fulfilled is a matter of God’s will alone.