If someone is a disbeliever but loves Imam Ali (AS), can we say that although he is a disbeliever and deserves punishment and to abide eternally in Hell, that punishment is not yet established as actual for him?
And does “O Allah, befriend those who befriend him” include such a disbeliever?
Does a disbeliever who loves Imam Ali (AS) fall under “O Allah, befriend those who befriend him”?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A disbeliever cannot love the Master of the Believers, Amir al-Mu'minin Ali (AS), because love of him is inseparable from faith, and the Prophet (PBUH) said: “Only a believer loves Ali, and none but a disbeliever harbours enmity toward him.” God does not love disbelievers, and Ali (AS) is the path of divine love. Therefore, a disbeliever cannot fall under the supplication “O Allah, befriend those who befriend him.”
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA disbeliever cannot love our master, Amir al-Mu’minin, peace be upon him.
Love for our master is possible only on the condition of faith!
قال النبی ص لا یحب علیا إلا مؤمن و لا یبغضه إلا کافر.
ʿUyūn Akhbār al-Riḍā, vol. 2, p. 63
Only a believer loves ʿAlī, and none but a disbeliever hates him.
God Most High does not love disbelievers! And ʿAlī, peace be upon him, is the path to divine love. ʿAlī, peace be upon him, does not love the disbeliever. In the contest of love and affection, the love shown by the created being is a response to God’s love: ( یحبهم و یحبونه). The conclusion, therefore, is that a disbeliever is not permitted to love ʿAlī, peace be upon him!
آلعمران : 32 قل أطیعوا الله و الرسول فإن تولوا فإن الله لا یحب الکافرین
الروم : 45 لیجزی الذین آمنوا و عملوا الصالحات من فضله إنه لا یحب الکافرین
Love necessarily entails following, and, in reality, following is the true sign and proof of love.
اللهم وال من والاه
Thus, whoever loves ʿAlī, peace be upon him, enters upon the path of ʿAlī.