Does criticizing and clarifying the polytheistic, blasphemous, or deviant statements and writings of individuals—even those who are ostensibly scholars—amount to declaring them unbelievers?
(For context: I shared some of Mr. Hassan-Zadeh’s statements of kufr, with a brief explanation, in a group. They called me “English,” accused me of takfīr, and blocked me from sending messages. Their evidence for justifying these statements of kufr was a photo of the Leader visiting Mr. Hassan-Zadeh, and the fact that Mr. Hassan-Zadeh had said: “Keep your ears tuned to the Leader, because his ears are tuned to the Hujjah!”)
Does Criticizing Polytheistic and Deviant Statements Amount to Takfīr?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Silence in the face of polytheistic words and actions amounts to supporting their escalation. Nothing and no one is more beloved than God, and no insult is more vile than shirk. Defending tawḥīd is part of fulfilling our duty to worship God. People’s support for prominent figures neither justifies their polytheistic statements nor makes them legitimate.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSilence in the face of words and actions that constitute shirk supports their escalation. Nothing and no one is dearer than God, and no insult is more vile than shirk. Defending tawhid is fulfilling our duty of servitude to God.
His support for the leader is no proof that his words and writings are trustworthy. He cannot absolve himself by hiding in the shadow of his own eminent figures, nor lend legitimacy and acceptance to his words of shirk.