With reference to Sermon 93 of Nahj al-Balagha, which begins with the words «فاسالونی قبل ان تفقدونی», can we say that the Imam of the Age knows the exact day of his appearance—and even knows whether or not we pray, though our prayers may hasten or delay what is decreed? I’m not sure how to put my question. Is the Imam of the Age (AS) distressed because he knows when he will appear? Thank you.
Does the Imam of the Age Know the Day of His Appearance and Hear Our Prayers?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God grants knowledge of the unseen to whomever He wills, and those who possess such knowledge know that it is by God’s will. The time of the appearance is certain, yet prayer can change it, and the Imam of the Age (AJ) asks us to pray for his appearance to be hastened. If the time of the appearance can be changed and we pray for it, then its timing remains unknown. God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterGod grants knowledge of the unseen to whomever He wills. Those who possess knowledge of the unseen know with certainty that the unseen and what is divinely decreed are made certain by God’s will; and if He wills, He has the power to change anything. God knows whatever is to come, whether it is to be confirmed or changed!
Laws and ordinances are subject to the Lord; knowledge of the unseen is subject to His all-conquering power, while His incomparable essence is subject to nothing.
It is no cause for wonder that the revered Imams possess knowledge of the unseen, including the time of the Appearance, for divine will governs it. Yet this knowledge is also bound up with the awareness that every decree is made by God and its confirmation depends on His will: if He so wills, He changes it!
الرعد : 39 یمحوا الله ما یشاء و یثبت و عنده أم الکتاب
God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills, and with Him is the Mother of the Book!
Our master, the Commander of the Faithful, عليه السلام, is both باب الله and علم الله. With this divinely granted power, he calls out: سلونی قبل أن تفقدونی سلونی
And through this God-given knowledge, he knows that his knowledge depends on the will of God, the All-Knowing!
علی بن أبی طالب علیهم السلام: «و الله لو لا آیه فی کتاب الله لحدثناکم بما یکون إلى أن تقوم الساعه: یمحوا الله ما یشاء و یثبت و عنده أم الکتاب .
Ali ibn Abi Talib, علیهم السلام, said: “By God, were it not for a verse in the Book of God, I would tell you what will happen until the Day of Resurrection: ‘God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills, and with Him is the Mother of the Book.’”
With this knowledge, then, they put their own knowledge to use in seeking a change in the divine decree concerning the unseen, asking the Lord for even greater kindness, grace, and generosity!
It is no strange thing if the Imam of our time, علیه السلام, knows when his Appearance will take place. Yet the Imam himself asks us to pray abundantly for his Appearance to be hastened. To hasten the Appearance is to change its appointed time.
و أکثروا الدعاء بتعجیل الفرج فإن ذلک فرجکم
The Imam of our time, علیه السلام, said: “Pray often for the hastening of relief, for in that lies your own relief.”
To seek a change in the time of the Appearance and pray for it means that its time becomes unknown!!!
عن أبی حمزه الثمالی قال سمعت أبا جعفر ع یقول یا ثابت إن الله تبارک و تعالى قد کان وقت هذا الأمر فی السبعین فلما أن قتل الحسین صلوات الله علیه اشتد غضب الله تعالى على أهل الأرض فأخره إلى أربعین و مائه فحدثناکم فأذعتم الحدیث فکشفتم قناع الستر و لم یجعل الله له بعد ذلک وقتا عندنا و یمحوا الله ما یشاء و یثبت و عنده أم الکتاب قال أبو حمزه فحدثت بذلک أبا عبد الله ع فقال قد کان کذلک.
Abu Hamza al-Thumali said: I heard Abu Ja‘far say, “O Thabit, God, Blessed and Exalted, had appointed this affair for the year seventy. But when al-Husayn, صلوات الله علیه, was killed, God’s anger against the people of the earth grew fierce, so He postponed it until the year one hundred and forty. Then we told you about it, and you spread the report, lifting the veil. After that, God set no time for it with us. God effaces whatever He wills and confirms whatever He wills, and with Him is the Mother of the Book.” Abu Hamza said: I told Abu ‘Abd Allah about this, and he said, “That is how it was.”
عن عبد الرحمن بن کثیر قال: کنت عند أبی عبد الله ع إذ دخل علیه مهزم فقال له جعلت فداک أخبرنی عن هذا الأمر الذی ننتظر متى هو فقال یا مهزم کذب الوقاتون و هلک المستعجلون و نجا المسلمون.
‘Abd al-Rahman ibn Kathir said: I was with Abu ‘Abd Allah when Muhzim came in and said to him, “May I be your ransom, tell me: when will this affair that we await take place?” He replied, “O Muhzim, those who set times have lied; those who are impatient have perished; and those who submit have been saved.”
عن أبی بصیر عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: سألته عن القائم ع فقال کذب الوقاتون إنا أهل بیت لا نوقت.
Abu Basir said: I asked Abu ‘Abd Allah about al-Qa’im, and he replied, “Those who set times have lied. We are a household that does not set a time.”
أحمد بإسناده قال: قال أبى الله إلا أن یخالف وقت الموقتین.
Ahmad reports through his chain of transmission that he said: “God wills nothing but that it contradict the time set by those who set times.”
عن الفضیل بن یسار عن أبی جعفر ع قال: قلت لهذا الأمر وقت فقال کذب الوقاتون کذب الوقاتون کذب الوقاتون إن موسى ع لما خرج وافدا إلى ربه واعدهم ثلاثین یوما فلما زاده الله على الثلاثین عشرا قال قومه قد أخلفنا موسى فصنعوا ما صنعوا فإذا حدثناکم الحدیث فجاء على ما حدثناکم به فقولوا صدق الله و إذا حدثناکم الحدیث فجاء على خلاف ما حدثناکم به فقولوا صدق الله تؤجروا مرتین .
Fudayl ibn Yasar relates: I asked Imam al-Baqir علیه السلام, “Is a time set for this cause?” He replied, “Those who set times are liars. Those who set times are liars. Those who set times are liars. When Moses علیه السلام went to his Lord as a messenger, he promised his people thirty days. Then, when God added ten more days to the thirty, his people said, ‘Moses has broken his promise to us,’ and did what they did”—that is, they worshipped the calf. “So, if we tell you something and it comes to pass as we told you, say, ‘God has spoken the truth.’ And if we tell you something and it comes to pass contrary to what we told you, say, ‘God has spoken the truth.’ In this way, you will earn a double reward.”
Usul al-Kafi / Mustafawi translation, vol. 2, p. 192
علی بن یقطین قال: قال لی أبو الحسن ع الشیعه تربى بالأمانی منذ مائتی سنه:" قال و قال یقطین لابنه علی بن یقطین ما بالنا قیل لنا فکان و قیل لکم فلم یکن قال فقال له علی إن الذی قیل لنا و لکم کان من مخرج واحد غیر أن أمرکم حضر فأعطیتم محضه فکان کما قیل لکم و إن أمرنا لم یحضر فعللنا بالأمانی فلو قیل لنا إن هذا الأمر لا یکون إلا إلى مائتی سنه أو ثلاثمائه سنه لقست القلوب و لرجع عامه الناس عن الإسلام و لکن قالوا ما أسرعه و ما أقربه تألفا لقلوب الناس و تقریبا للفرج.
Ali ibn Yaqtin relates: Musa ibn Ja'far علیه السلام said to me, “For two hundred years, the Shi'a have been nurtured on hopes.” When Ali told his father—Yaqtin, who served in the court of al-Saffah and al-Mansur—what the Imam had said, Yaqtin asked his son, “Why is it that what was foretold about us comes to pass, while what was foretold about you does not?” Ali replied, “What was foretold about us and about you came from the same source”—that is, revelation, conveyed to people through Gabriel, the Prophet and the Imams علیهم السلام. “But your time had come, so you were given its full reality, and things came to pass as you had been told. Our time has not yet come, so we are kept going by hopes. If we were told that this cause would not come about for another two or three hundred years, hearts would grow hard and most people would turn away from Islam. Instead, they say, ‘How soon it will come! How near it is!’—to win people’s hearts and bring the relief closer.”
Usul al-Kafi / Mustafawi translation, vol. 2, p. 193
عن إبراهیم بن مهزم عن أبیه عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: ذکرنا عنده ملوک آل فلان فقال إنما هلک الناس من استعجالهم لهذا الأمر إن الله لا یعجل لعجله العباد إن لهذا الأمر غایه ینتهی إلیها فلو قد بلغوها لم یستقدموا ساعه و لم یستأخروا.
Ibrahim ibn Mahzam relates from his father: We spoke in the presence of Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام about the rulers of the family of so-and-so—that is, the Abbasids. He said, “People have perished only because they have been impatient for this cause. God does not hasten in response to His servants’ haste. This cause has an appointed end, which it must reach. Once it reaches that point, it will neither come an hour early nor be delayed by an hour.”