Peace be upon you. Does the supplication known as Nad-e Ali have a reliable chain of transmission and text?
Does the Nad-e Ali Supplication Have a Reliable Text and Chain of Transmission?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Nad-e Ali poem is attributed to the Prophet of Islam (PBUH) through an unlinked chain of transmission, and its chain is not considered reliable. However, there is no objection to reciting it with an understanding of what is due to God and His chosen servants, with a heart grounded in tawhid, and without placing Imam Ali (AS) in God’s stead. It should be remembered that Mawla Ali (AS) is the Lord’s greatest sign.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe poem *Nād-e ʿAlī* has been transmitted from the Prophet of Islam صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم as a mursal report—that is, its chain of transmission is not reliable. However, reciting it «عارفا بحق الله و اولیائه», with a heart grounded in monotheism and an understanding of the order of causes, without forgetting God, and without substituting expressions of love for and appeal to the Imam for devotion to the Almighty, is unobjectionable. We should bear in mind that the Master, ʿAlī علیه السلام, is the Supreme Sign of God Most High: remembering him should cause remembrance of the Majestic One to well up in our hearts, not cause remembrance of God to fade.
The poem *Nād-e ʿAlī* has been subject to considerable misuse. Some have added lines to it and prescribed practices that are not without problems.
قال: و یقال إن النبی ص نودی فی هذا الیوم
ناد علیا مظهر العجائب تجده عونا لک فی النوائب
کل غم و هم سینجلی بولایتک یا علی یا علی یا علی
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج20، ص: 73
Allama Majlesi comments on these lines as follows:
الجمله الأخیره فیها غرابه و لا تلائم سابقها، و الظاهر أنها من زیاده بعض الجهله، او الصوفیه المضله الذین یزعمون أن هذه الجملات تکون دعاء فیذکرونها وردا و ذکرا، غفله عن معناها، بل بعضهم یرون للمداومه على ذکرها فضیله لیست للصلاه، حفظنا الله عن البدع و اتباع الاهواء.