In explaining “کمال الاخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه,” when we ask you how unity can be denied of the divine Essence, your answer so far has been that God’s unity is a unity beyond unity. That is correct. But I think the problem lies in your use of the word “essence” when you say, “The attributes must be denied of the divine Essence.” This statement of yours is not without difficulty, and so I would like to offer an explanation.
حضرت علی علیه السلام says: “کمال الاخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه.” By the divine Essence, we should understand that all the attributes, despite their conceptual multiplicity, speak of “one reality.” For example, God Almighty’s mercy and wrath both point to one and the same Essence. “The Essence, then, is the one reality manifested through different names and attributes.”
This statement, in itself, makes clear that the divine Essence is “knowable in a relative sense.” Therefore, the attributes cannot be denied of the divine Essence; rather, we must hold that the attributes are identical with the Essence. The meaning of the hadith “کمال الاخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه” is therefore not that the attributes are to be denied of God Almighty’s Essence. In other words, the divine Essence can be known through His Most Beautiful Names and attributes, and His attributes are identical with His Essence, because they direct us to the “One Essence”—whose very unity we are incapable of knowing. From this perspective, we can explain the state of prayer: when we pray sincerely, we turn our attention to God’s Essence and bring all His attributes and Most Beautiful Names to bear upon it at once, without focusing on any particular attribute. This is a relative knowledge of His Essence. Yet we all acknowledge that “what cannot be known is the innermost reality and true nature of God Almighty.” Surely you agree with this as well. So the hadith above can readily be rendered as follows: “کمال الاخلاص له نفی الصفات عنه”: “The perfection of sincerity is to deny the attributes of God’s innermost reality and true nature” (not of His Essence). I have often understood you to mean this in your own statements as well. Perhaps, however, your difficulty is that, while accepting this meaning, you still deny the attributes of the “Essence” and use the phrase “denying the attributes of the Essence.” But you should say, “denying the attributes of the innermost reality and true nature.” It seems, then, that you have simply chosen the wrong word. Otherwise, you too surely deny the attributes of God’s innermost reality and true nature.
In summary, I understand the distinction to be between two things: 1) the divine Essence, and 2) the innermost reality and true nature of God. The divine Essence can be known through the Names, and is veiled by His Names and attributes. In fact, His Names and attributes are manifestations of that same Essence, which we call unity, because His Essence is the reality that encompasses the conceptual multiplicity of the Names and attributes. When we turn our attention strongly to God in our prayers, we are no longer focused on just one particular attribute; rather, we hold all His attributes in mind together. This is tawḥīd (though still incomplete and tainted by association). And this is what it means to turn one’s attention to the Essence. (God willing, we will learn the higher and more complete degree of tawḥīd from the Infallibles themselves, علیهم السلام.) Thus, the Essence is knowable, because the divine Essence is manifested through His Names and attributes; the Essence itself, in turn, manifests the divine innermost reality and true nature, which can never be known and to which no understanding can attain. Therefore, what cannot be known, and from which the attributes must be denied, is the innermost reality and true nature of God Almighty. Denying the attributes means denying them of God’s innermost reality and true nature, not of His Essence.