Peace be upon you. Is there a problem with this phrase from the perspective of tawhid: "هو یا علی"?
Does the phrase “هو یا علی” pose a problem from the perspective of tawhid?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The phrase "هو یا علی" is likely one of the litanies used by those who go to extremes. Using names exclusive to God for human beings transgresses the bounds of tawhid and may amount to shirk. The Imams (AS) reject exaggeration about them and advise us to regard them as servants nurtured by God and to avoid excess.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterIt seems to be one of the liturgies of the extremists!
Using names reserved for God Most High to describe His servants is a transgression of the bounds of tawḥīd and an entry into the very heart of shirk.
يا هادي المضلين أخرج البغض و المنكر و الغلو لأمينك أمير المؤمنين و الأئمه من ولده من قلوبنا و نفوسنا و ألسنتنا و همومنا
Iqbāl al-Aʿmāl (old edition), vol. 1, p. 452
O Guide of those who have gone astray, remove from our hearts, souls, tongues, and thoughts all hostility, denial, and exaggeration concerning the Commander of the Faithful and his descendants.
إياكم و الغلو فينا قولوا إنا عباد مربوبون و قولوا في فضلنا ما شئتم من أحبنا فليعمل بعملنا و يستعن بالورع فإنه أفضل ما يستعان به في الدنيا و الآخره
Tuḥaf al-ʿUqūl, text, p. 104
Beware of any exaggeration concerning us. Call us servants nurtured by God, and then say whatever you wish about our excellence (do not raise us above the station of servanthood; beyond that, any virtue befits us)…
And al-Riḍā, peace be upon him, said likewise, adding:
و من تجاوز بأمير المؤمنين ع العبوديه- فهو من المغضوب عليهم و من الضالين.
و قال أمير المؤمنين ع: «لا تتجاوزوا بنا العبوديه، ثم قولوا ما شئتم و لن تبلغوا و إياكم و الغلو كغلو النصارى، فإني بريء من الغالين».
The exegesis attributed to Imam al-Ḥasan al-ʿAskarī, peace be upon him, p. 51
Imam al-Riḍā, peace be upon him, said: “Whoever takes the Commander of the Faithful, peace be upon him, beyond the bounds of servanthood is among those who have incurred God’s wrath and those who have gone astray.”
The Commander of the Faithful, peace be upon him, said: “Do not take us beyond the bounds of servanthood; then say whatever you wish, for you will never attain our true rank. Beware of exaggeration like that of the Christians, for I disavow those who exaggerate.”