Please critique the following statement:
Ayatollah Javadi Amoli:
‼ Satan’s temptations are a blessing and a mercy,
because everyone who has attained a high station did so by triumphing in the struggle against temptation in the arena of the greater jihad.
A Critique of the Claim “Satan’s Temptations Are a Blessing and a Mercy”
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Struggling against Satan’s temptations in the arena of the greater jihad can lead to mercy and higher spiritual stations, but the temptation itself is not a mercy. Satan and his deeds are vile, and we must avoid them. What is meant by mercy is the divine opportunity for growth and progress—a test that a servant emerges from with honor.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe respected author’s intention in making the point in question is entirely clear. In effect, he regards the outcome of Satan’s whisperings for a believer who resists them as a mercy. But the word “whispering” has no place among the manifestations of divine mercy. God Most High is the creator of both good and evil, but good belongs to the realm of intellect, while evil belongs to the realm of ignorance. Ignorance, in turn, belongs to the sphere of ignorance and its forces; it does not belong to the circle of intellect, which is a manifestation of divine mercy.
Satan is vile, and his act—whispering—is vile as well. By avoiding what is vile and impure—that is, by keeping away from Satan and his whisperings—the believer attains divine mercy.
Any attempt to call whispering a mercy only makes things difficult for the audience. Such a label creates needless difficulty for the speaker, who must justify the point, and for the audience, who must decide whether to accept or reject it. Yet the same intention could be conveyed easily by using appropriate terminology.
If we call whispering a mercy, then, since Satan is a tempter, we would have to make the plainly mistaken claim that Satan the tempter is Satan, the possessor of mercy—even though Satan is always accursed.
Calling whispering a mercy therefore makes the claim difficult to defend, and may well confuse the audience about the questions of mercy and retribution that lie ahead.
We could call the experience of temptation a merciful opportunity given by the Lord for His servants to advance and make progress, since a servant who passes this test with distinction attains high stations. Surely this is what the author intends.
If whispering is a mercy, we should place ourselves in its path, not flee from it.
Although the author’s intention in making this point is perfectly clear, we must accept that, apart from the Prophet’s Household, no one is infallible in the way they express themselves or use words. Acknowledging the slips of eminent scholars is a way of honoring the noble station of knowledge.
Let us remember that we must turn away and flee from divine wrath, and hasten toward His mercy. Likewise, we should shun Satan’s whisperings and seek refuge in God from their evil.
اذا وسوس الشیطان الی أحدکم، فلیتعوذ بالله ولیقل: «آمنت بالله وبرسوله صلیالله علیه و آله مخلصا له الدین».
Whenever Satan whispers to one of you, let him seek refuge in God from its evil and say, “اعوذ بالله منالشیطان الرجیم آمنت بالله و برسوله صلیالله علیه و آله مخلصا له الدین”.