Thank you.
So this hadith does not appear in manuscripts from before our time, even with a weak chain of transmission?
Does the Shurusi Shamasi Hadith Appear in Manuscripts from Before Our Time?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Shurusi Shamasi hadith is mentioned in none of the manuscripts from before our time, nor in books of either fabricated or non-fabricated reports. This text is entirely new and was fabricated by modern forgers.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterPlease pay particularly close attention to the replies.
Before anyone quoted this fabricated text—علیه و علیه—it appeared in no book, whether a collection of fabricated reports or otherwise. This text is a recent invention. Its fabricators have only just made it up, عليهم لعنه و العذاب !!!
+1
And when you said it contained fabricated text, do you have access to the original text of this hadith? Please send it to me.
#Reply 2147 +1
Dear Sayyid, please read the replies carefully, so that, God forbid, you do not accuse anyone or falsely attribute something to them!
Where in the reply does it say that it contains fabricated text??? Rather, it says “fabricated text” (= “fabricated text”); “text” is the first term in an iḍāfa construction, not the subject (mubtada).
This text (the fabricated text) has only just entered the marketplace of discord; it’s fresh out of the oven. ان شاء الله it will soon go stale!!!