Given the sacred status and importance of Zamzam water, and the Shi’a perspective on it, how should we view recent studies that have found signs of toxicity in the water—possibly as a result of tampering or a conspiracy? Some people reportedly become reluctant to perform religious rites and acts of worship, and feel listless, after drinking it. In your view, can we still regard the water as sacred and take its special properties into account? If this is a conspiracy intended to diminish Shi’a Muslims’ ability to benefit from worship, over time it could also undermine the water’s sacred status.
How can we tell whether other things revered by Shi’a Muslims have likewise been distorted or altered? What approach should we take?
Does Zamzam Water Remain Sacred Despite Signs of Toxicity?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Zamzam water will always retain its authenticity and greatness, even if the actions and betrayal of unworthy custodians compromise its properties. We can distinguish truth from falsehood by holding fast to the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt, and we will not be deceived by distortions. Zamzam has been wronged and needs our prayers for its restoration.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterZamzam water lies in the throes of martyrdom.
The wrongs suffered by Zamzam water call to mind the wrongs suffered by Ali and his descendants.
Just as, despite all the injustice inflicted upon the Imams of the Household, they remain the rulers of the souls and hearts of humankind, so Zamzam water will preserve its purity and greatness for all eternity.
For centuries, the shameless adversaries have continued their negative propaganda against the Ahl al-Bayt علیهم السلام, especially Mawla Ali علیه السلام, sparing no insult or curse. Yet we see that the divine light shines more brightly than ever! Their efforts to extinguish that light have come to nothing; in the same way, their attempts to distort and debase the purity and properties of Zamzam water will come to nothing.
Zamzam water will remain Zamzam forever. The poisoned water presented in its place is like the tyrannical caliphs who usurped the place of Mawla Ali علیه السلام. Only those sick at heart turned away from Ali; the believers remained steadfast in their love for their Mawla.
In these days, Zamzam water has fallen victim to the injustice of its unworthy custodians, and the poison of betrayal has been added to its blessed being—like those revered ones who were martyred by poison.
In the Age of Occultation, thanks to their adherence to the Qur’an and the Ahl al-Bayt, the Shi‘a can readily discern the truth and separate gold from copper. So long as this great touchstone remains among us, we will not be deceived by any distortion or alteration. Woe betide us if ever it slips from our grasp!
Zamzam water is the truth; whatever has been done to it is falsehood. If it is freed from the captivity of its oppressive custodians, it will be revived once more. Zamzam is like a martyr lying in the throes of death, and we must pray for its salvation!