Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 584 4 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

How Are Fear and Hope Balanced Within a Person?

Primary reference: See the answer text 28 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Fear and hope are the two wings of faith, born of knowledge of God. Fear watches over and protects the heart, while hope intercedes on behalf of the soul. The balance between them leads a person to God’s good pleasure and keeps them from straying. Fear concerning one’s past and future actions, together with hope in divine grace, guides a person along the path of steadfastness.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The hadith attributed to Imam al-Sadiq (AS) answers your question beautifully!

قال الصادق (AS) الخوف رقیب القلب و الرجاء شفیع النفس و من کان بالله عارفا کان من الله خائفا و إلیه راجیا و هما جناحا الإیمان یطیر بهما العبد المحقق إلى رضوان الله و عینا عقله یبصر بهما إلى وعد الله تعالى و وعیده و الخوف طالع عدل الله باتقاء وعیده و الرجاء داعی فضل الله و هو یحیی القلب و الخوف یمیت النفس قال رسول الله (PBUH) المؤمن بین خوفین خوف ما مضى و خوف ما بقی و بموت النفس یکون حیاه القلب و بحیاه القلب البلوغ إلى الاستقامه و من عبد الله‏ تعالى على میزان الخوف و الرجاء لا یضل و یصل إلى مأموله و کیف لا یخاف العبد و هو غیر عالم بما یختم صحیفته و لا له عمل یتوسل به استحقاقا و لا قدره له على شی‏ء و لا مفر و کیف لا یرجو و هو یعرف نفسه بالعجز و هو غریق فی بحر آلاء الله و نعمائه من حیث لا تحصى و لا تعد و المحب یعبد ربه على الرجاء بمشاهده أحواله بعین سهر و الزاهد یعبد على الخوف قال أویس لهرم بن حیان قد عمل الناس على الرجاء فقال بل تعمل على الخوف و الخوف خوفان ثابت و معارض فالثابت من الخوف یورث الرجاء و المعارض منه یورث خوفا ثابتا و الرجاء رجاءان منه عاکف و باد فالعاکف منه یورث خوفا ثابتا یقوی نسبه المحبه و البادی منه یصح أمل العجز و التقصیر و الحیاه
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 180

Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Fear watches over the heart, guarding and protecting it from danger, harm, and blameworthy deeds. Hope in God, the Compassionate and Forgiving, intercedes for the human soul, drawing it close to the Most High Lord and to His mercy, kindness, and grace, and making it a recipient of divine generosity and mercy.

“Fear is the fruit of knowledge: the more fully one comes to know the Real, the greater one’s fear of being called to account and of disobeying Him. Fear and hope are the two wings of faith. With their help, the servant who is striving to attain and establish a spiritual station makes his way to the abode of the Almighty Lord’s good pleasure. Fear and hope are also the two eyes of human reason, through which it looks toward God’s promises and warnings. Fear guides a person to the path of justice, safety, and assurance, and keeps him away from what God has warned against and forbidden, and from harm and affliction. Hope calls a person toward the Most High Lord’s grace, generosity, and kindness, and brings spiritual light and life to the heart.

“Fear, meanwhile, gradually extinguishes the ego: it puts an end to self-admiration, self-will, and following the lower self.”

The Noble Prophet (PBUH) said: “The believer stands between two fears: fear of his past deeds and former conduct, and fear of what lies ahead and of the course his future affairs will take.”

It should be remembered that the ego stands opposed to the human heart and spirit. The weaker one side becomes, the stronger the other grows; when one is extinguished, the other comes to life and endures forever. When the human heart gains spiritual life and true illumination, a person attains steadfastness and stands firm on God’s path of truth.

Whoever proceeds by the measure of fear and hope, with these two wings, will never stray from the straight path or the way of truth, justice, and right conduct; rather, they will be granted success in reaching their desired goal.

How could anyone feel no fear or anxiety about the past and future of their affairs, when they do not know how their record of deeds has been filled, how it will end, what station their inner self and its true nature have reached, or with what qualities they will fill the page of their heart? Nor will they have any deed or effort on which to rely, or by virtue of which they might deserve the desired outcome and a beautiful reward. For if they are granted success in doing good, it will be through the attention and care of God Most High. They must also remember that they themselves can never, by their own inherent strength and power, perform a good deed or refrain from a wrongful one, for all power and strength belong to God Most High alone.

And how could anyone fail to hope in the grace, mercy, and kindness of God Most High, or consider themselves to have no need of hope, when they know better than anyone the state of their outward and inward being, their strength and power, and their public and private deeds? They know with absolute certainty that they are incapable, weak, and powerless when it comes to fulfilling the duties prescribed by servitude to God, and that they also fall short in expressing gratitude for the blessings of God Most High. For God’s outward and inward blessings, and His universal and particular mercies, encompass His servants so completely that they could never possibly give thanks for them as they ought.

Thus, the believer worships and fulfils their duty in the spirit of hope, as an expression of love. They know the true worth of their deeds and the state of their inner being; with wakeful, clear-sighted vision, they see their own shortcomings, helplessness, need, poverty, and utter dependence. They do not mistake what they see. And in the spirit of asceticism and piety, mindful of God Most High’s might and irresistible power, they worship in a state of fear. Uways al-Qarani said to his companion Hirm ibn Hayyan—both among the great figures of spiritual knowledge—“People act on the basis of hope, but we must act on the basis of fear; we must never make ourselves feel secure through hope.” Both fear and hope are divided into two kinds: abiding and transient.

Abiding fear is firmly established in the human heart through knowledge, faith, and piety. It is active at every step and in every deed. Once a believer is characterized by this quality, the ground for hope takes root in their heart, for hope without the realization of piety, good conduct, vigilance in one’s spiritual wayfaring, and caution on the path is misplaced.

Transient fear has not yet reached the degree of firmness and realization. It appears at times and then passes away. If this kind of fear is attended to, it will become abiding fear. Abiding, steadfast hope is firmly and deeply rooted in the human heart. This quality reveals the depth and constancy of love and attachment; to abide means to remain in a place, bound to it and held there.

Nascent, transient hope appears and shines forth from time to time. Gradually, its emergence establishes within the heart a true awareness of helplessness, shortcoming, and poverty, and firmly instils the quality of modesty and shame in the face of God’s majesty, kindness, and mercies.

مصباح الشریعه / translated by Mostafavi, text, p. 399

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022