Given the distinctive creation of the people of the right and the left, can we conclude that people’s good or bad destinies were fully determined even before creation, and that they were created accordingly? Wouldn’t that contradict free will? Of course, the hadith says that the servants themselves are responsible. But if their natures have differed from the very beginning of creation, how can that be reconciled with free will? Does the answer ultimately come back to the primordial realm and so on?
How Can Human Destiny Be Reconciled with Free Will?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Human nature, formed from earth and water, is interwoven with a person’s essential reality, and the correspondence between the two determines whether their destiny is good or bad. The believer is created from the clay of ʿIlliyyīn, and the disbeliever from the clay of Sijjīn. This difference in their clay does not prevent them from choosing freely; rather, it provides the basis for their essential nature to accord with their destiny.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA rose seed sprouts in rose soil.
The hand and the left and right sides are not, in themselves, negative aspects of existence!
The clay from which a human being is formed has nothing to do with the reality and essence of that person. The human reality is like a seed placed in the heart of the soil (clay). That soil must suit the seed’s structure and characteristics; otherwise, it will not grow. Not every seed grows in every field or soil. A seed can flourish only in soil suited to its nature.
The Creative, All-Knowing Creator fashioned a particular clay and soil suited to the reality of the human being, and formed the human being’s inner and outer faculties and organs from those elements (that clay). A believer is like a flower seed that draws only its own particular elements from the soil, and yields fragrance, nectar, freshness, and beauty. If there are impurities in that soil, the seed either does not grow or refuses to absorb them. But poisonous plants grow in the soil suited to them, and ...
Thus, each person’s essence and reality are bound up with, and suited to, their particular clay. The believer and their reality are bound up with the clay of ʿIlliyyīn; the disbeliever and their reality are suited to the clay of Sijjīn, which the Creator created.
The bee’s home is in the hearts of pure, beautiful flowers; the beetle’s home is in swamps and filthy places! The heart steeped in the filth of sin is the disbeliever’s resting place!
النور : 26 الخبیثات للخبیثین و الخبیثون للخبیثات و الطیبات للطیبین و الطیبون للطیبات أولئک مبرؤن مما یقولون لهم مغفره و رزق کریم
عن علی بن الحسین ع قال: إن الله عز و جل خلق النبیین من طینه علیین قلوبهم و أبدانهم و خلق قلوب المؤمنین من تلک الطینه و جعل خلق أبدان المؤمنین من دون ذلک و خلق الکفار من طینه سجین قلوبهم و أبدانهم فخلط بین الطینتین- فمن هذا یلد المؤمن الکافر و یلد الکافر المؤمن و من هاهنا یصیب المؤمن السیئه و من هاهنا یصیب الکافر الحسنه فقلوب المؤمنین تحن إلى ما خلقوا منه و قلوب الکافرین تحن إلى ما خلقوا منه.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 3
عن أبی حمزه الثمالی قال سمعت أبا جعفر ع یقول إن الله جل و عز خلقنا من أعلى علیین و خلق قلوب شیعتنا مما خلقنا منه و خلق أبدانهم من دون ذلک و قلوبهم تهوی إلینا لأنها خلقت مما خلقنا منه ثم تلا هذه الآیه کلا إن کتاب الأبرار لفی علیین و ما أدراک ما علیون کتاب مرقوم یشهده المقربون و خلق عدونا من سجین و خلق قلوب شیعتهم مما خلقهم منه و أبدانهم من دون ذلک فقلوبهم تهوی إلیهم لأنها خلقت مما خلقوا منه ثم تلا هذه الآیه- کلا إن کتاب الفجار لفی سجین و ما أدراک ما سجین کتاب مرقوم ویل یومئذ للمکذبین
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج2، ص: 3