Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 1342 20 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

How Can I Tell a Satanic Dream from a Divine One?

Primary reference: See the answer text 38 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-1342

In light of this account:

**Why the day is called عرفه:** The reason for this name is that on the night of Tarwiyah, Abraham, peace be upon him, dreamed that someone was telling him, “God commands you to sacrifice your son.” When morning came, he wondered whether the dream was from God or from Satan. This day was therefore named یوم الترویه, meaning “the day of reflection.” On the second night, he had the same dream and was told to make a vow. When morning came, he understood and knew that the dream was from Allah. It was therefore named یوم عرفه, meaning the day on which he understood and recognized that command. On the third night, he had the same dream again and resolved to sacrifice his son. This day was therefore named یوم النحر, meaning “the day of sacrifice.”

Imam Qurtubi, رحمه الله, writes: «ویقال : إن إبراهیم رأى فی لیله الترویه کأن قائلا یقول : إن الله یأمرک بذبح ابنک؛ فلما أصبح روى فی نفسه أی فکر أهذا الحلم من الله أم من الشیطان؟ فسمی یوم الترویه . فلما کانت اللیله الثانیه رأى ذلک أیضا وقیل له الوعد ، فلما أصبح عرف أن ذلک من الله فسمی یوم عرفه . ثم رأى مثله فی اللیله الثالثه فهم بنحره فسمی یوم النحر . (تفسیر القرطبی موافق للمطبوع – (15 / 102)

How can one distinguish a satanic dream from a divine one? And can a Messenger of God also face the difficulty of doubting whether a dream is satanic or divine?

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Divinely inspired dreams bring glad tidings and spiritual effects. Inner reassurance, steadfastness, presence of heart, humility, and reverence are among the most important signs of true dreams. Such dreams bring about a spiritual transformation and serve as a catalyst for change and growth. God provides outward signs to confirm true dreams.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

The most familiar melody is the Creator’s pure word

The passage above sounds more like a fanciful tale than a reliable account. Such claims are far removed from the sanctity of Abraham’s station. Doubt and uncertainty are signs of associating partners with God; certainty was the very spirit and essence of Abraham. Until a prophet attains certainty, the gate of revelation is not opened to his heart. The bond between the Creator and His envoy and messenger is the clearest kind of communication.

Arafah began with Adam, peace be upon him, and continued through Abraham to the Seal of the Prophets, blessings and peace be upon him and his family.

We were present with our father Adam, peace be upon him, at Arafat on the Day of Arafah. While in his loins, we joined him in intimate communion with the Self-Sufficient One and nurtured within ourselves the spirit of servanthood.

Arafah has a special connection with recognition and confession. Confession is the straight and level road to knowing the human self. We confess our sins to the One we worship—not so that He may learn of our sins, God forbid, but so that we may become aware of the illness within our souls and cling fast to the hem of our physician, lest we lose the spirit of servanthood to the pain of apostasy, sin, disobedience, and separation from the One we worship.

فسیر القمی أبی عن ابن أبی عمیر عن أبان بن عثمان عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: إن آدم ع بقی على الصفا أربعین صباحا ساجدا یبکی على الجنه و على خروجه من جوار الله عز و جل فنزل علیه جبرئیل ع فقال یا آدم ما لک تبکی قال یا جبرئیل ما لی لا أبکی و قد أخرجنی الله من جواره و أهبطنی إلى الدنیا قال یا آدم تب إلیه قال و کیف أتوب فأنزل الله علیه قبه من نور فی موضع البیت- فسطع نورها فی جبال مکه فهو الحرم فأمر الله جبرئیل أن یضع علیه الأعلام قال قم یا آدم فخرج به یوم الترویه و أمره أن یغتسل و یحرم و أخرج من الجنه أول یوم من ذی القعده فلما کان یوم الثامن من ذی الحجه أخرجه جبرئیل ع إلى منى فبات بها فلما أصبح أخرجه إلى عرفات و قد کان علمه حین أخرجه من مکه الإحرام و أمره بالتلبیه فلما زالت الشمس یوم العرفه قطع التلبیه و أمره أن یغتسل فلما صلى العصر وقفه بعرفات و علمه الکلمات التی تلقى بها ربه و هو سبحانک اللهم و بحمدک لا إله إلا أنت عملت سوءا و ظلمت نفسي و اعترفت بذنبي فاغفر لي إنك أنت الغفور الرحيم سبحانك اللهم و بحمدك لا إله إلا أنت عملت سوءا و ظلمت نفسي و اعترفت بذنبي فاغفر لي إنك أنت خير الغافرين سبحانك اللهم و بحمدك لا إله إلا أنت عملت سوءا و ظلمت نفسي و اعترفت بذنبي فاغفر لي إنك التواب الرحيم- فبقي إلى أن غابت الشمس رافعا يديه إلى السماء يتضرع و يبكي إلى الله فلما غابت الشمس رده إلى المشعر «1» فبات بها فلما أصبح قام على المشعر الحرام فدعا الله تعالى بكلمات «2» و تاب عليه ثم أفضى إلى منى و أمره جبرئیل ع أن يحلق الشعر الذي عليه فحلقه ثم رده إلى مکه فأتى به عند الجمره الأولى فعرض إبليس له عندها فقال يا آدم أین تريد فأمره جبرئیل أن يرميه بسبع حصيات و أن يكبر مع كل حصاه تكبيره ففعل ثم ذهب فعرض له إبليس عند الجمره الثانيه فأمره أن يرميه بسبع حصيات فرمى و كبر مع كل حصاه تكبيره ثم مضى به فعرض له‏ إبليس عند الجمره الثالثه و أمره أن يرميه بسبع حصيات فرمى و كبر مع كل حصاه تكبيره فذهب إبليس و قال له جبرئیل ع إنك لن تراه بعد هذا «1» أبدا فانطلق به إلى البيت الحرام و أمره أن يطوف به سبع مرات ففعل فقال له إن الله قد قبل توبتك و حلت لك زوجتك فقال فلما قضى آدم حجه لقيته الملائكه بالأبطح فقالوا يا آدم بر حجك «2» أما إنا قد حججنا قبلك هذا البيت بألفي عام .
بحار الأنوار (ط - بيروت)، ج‏11، ص: 178

عن معاويه بن عمار قال سألت أبا عبد الله ع عن عرفات لم سمیت عرفات فقال إن جبرئیل ع خرج بإبراهیم ص يوم عرفه فلما زالت الشمس قال له جبرئیل يا إبراهیم اعترف بذنبك و اعرف مناسكك فسميت عرفات لقول جبرئیل ع اعترف فاعترف‏
علل الشرائع، ج‏2، ص: 436

#Supplement1342 Thank you. Master, what signs and indications can help distinguish a satanic dream from a divine one?

#Supplement1342 Answer

Rahmanic dreams are accompanied by glad tidings and spiritual effects. Inner assurance is among the most important effects of true dreams. It means firmness of heart; a heart present in worship, and humility and reverence of heart, are among the clearest signs of this assurance.

Among the most obvious signs of satanic dreams are vanity, arrogance and pride afterward; baseless, boastful claims (مختال فخور); lethargy, listlessness and an absent heart in worship; and taking one’s duties of servitude lightly and neglecting them. If such people are religious, they may also display a rigid, narrow-minded religiosity, and so on.

Those whose words and hearts are truthful, and whose honesty endures after the dream, show that their dream is true and veridical!

The Creator of existence brings firmness to the heart of one who sees a true dream. God, the All-Merciful, strengthens and steadies the believer’s heart in assurance, firmness, faith and certainty, just as He does not abandon the believer’s heart while awake or leave it to its own devices.

القصص : 10 و أصبح فؤاد أم موسى‏ فارغا إن کادت لتبدی به لو لا أن ربطنا على‏ قلبها لتکون من المؤمنین

(At last) the heart of Moses’ mother became empty of all else (save the memory of her child). Had We not strengthened her heart (with faith and hope), she would almost have revealed the matter!

The hearts of the prophets are vessels for revelation, the divine Word and message. The Creator strengthens such hearts with certainty!

آل‏عمران : 41 قال رب اجعل لی‏ آیه قال آیتک ألا تکلم الناس ثلاثه أیام إلا رمزا و اذکر ربک کثیرا و سبح بالعشی و الإبکار

(Zakariya) said, “My Lord, appoint a sign for me!” He said, “Your sign is that for three days you will speak to people only by gestures. (Your tongue will cease to speak to them, though there will be no apparent cause.) Remember your Lord often (in gratitude for this great blessing), and glorify Him morning and evening!”

مریم : 10 قال رب اجعل لی‏ آیه قال آیتک ألا تکلم الناس ثلاث لیال سویا

He said, “My Lord, appoint a sign for me!” He replied, “Your sign is that for three days and nights you will be unable to speak to people, even though your tongue is sound!”

Rahmanic dreams bring about spiritual transformation and upheaval, with effects on individuals, communities and society. They are a catalyst for change, advancement and growth!

الإسراء : 60 و إذ قلنا لک إن ربک أحاط بالناس و ما جعلنا الرؤیا التی‏ أریناک إلا فتنه للناس و الشجره الملعونه فی القرآن و نخوفهم فما یزیدهم إلا طغیانا کبیرا

(Remember) when We said to you, “Your Lord encompasses all people (and is fully aware of their state). We made the vision We showed you only a trial for the people, as was the accursed tree mentioned in the Quran. We warn them, yet this only increases them in great rebellion!”

The All-Knowing God brings about outward signs to confirm true dreams!

الفتح : 27 لقد صدق الله رسوله الرؤیا بالحق لتدخلن المسجد الحرام إن شاء الله آمنین محلقین رؤسکم و مقصرین لا تخافون فعلم ما لم تعلموا فجعل من دون ذلک فتحا قریبا

God has confirmed as true the vision He showed His Messenger in a dream: by God’s will, you will surely enter the Sacred Mosque in complete safety, with your heads shaved or your hair cut short, fearing no one. But God knew what you did not know (and there was wisdom in this delay), and before that He granted you a near victory.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022