How can we call mental phenomena, and some abstract phenomena, created? Of course, God is the Creator of all phenomena. But some phenomena don’t have a tangible form of existence. They seem to come into being as a result of other phenomena—or even to be part of them—and don’t seem to exist independently or in a way we can grasp. Yet they are still considered created by God. I’d be grateful for some guidance on this. Thank you.
How Can Mental and Abstract Phenomena Be Considered Created by God?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Mental and abstract phenomena are considered created by God because their existence, continuity, and persistence depend on the will of the Creator, the Lord of the worlds. Just as the mind and the faculties it employs depend on God, the Creator, for their own existence and coming into being, so too do these phenomena.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterUnless the Creator wills into being the colors, the painter’s brush and design, and the painter himself, none of them can exist.
Mental concepts are images contained in the human mind. The mind depends on the will of the Creator, Lord of the Worlds, for its existence, endurance, and continued being. Likewise, the instruments the mind uses depend on God, the Creator, for their existence and realization, and for their coming into being as mental and abstract concepts. Unless the One God grants permission for mental and abstract concepts to be created, they do not come into being.