Peace be upon you. In light of this passage from the supplication for the time of occultation:
اللهم عرفنی نفسک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی نفسک لم أعرف رسولک اللهم عرفنی رسولک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی رسولک لم أعرف حجتک اللهم عرفنی حجتک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی حجتک ضللت عن دینی
The stages of knowing begin with knowing God; then, through knowing God, the Messenger is known, and through knowing the Messenger, God’s Proof can be known. How can this be reconciled with the hadith أنا مدینه العلم وعلی بابها، فمن أراد العلم فلیأت باب المدینه. which says that one can attain knowledge of the Messenger through the gate of the Proof?
How Can Knowing God, the Messenger, and the Proof Be Reconciled with the Hadith “أنا مدینة العلم”?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The stages of knowing in the supplication for the time of occultation begin with knowing God, then proceed to knowing the Messenger, and finally to knowing the Proof. The hadith “أنا مدینة العلم وعلی بابها” likewise leads from the gate of the Proof to the knowledge of the Messenger, so the two are compatible. “The Self of God” may be understood as the First Verse or as the source of the manifestation of the Muhammadan Light (PBUH).
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe one and only God is the creator of the universe and all that it contains. Unless the Creator wills creation, nothing will come into being. Likewise, unless He wills to impart knowledge to the souls of His creatures, no knowing creature will be found.
**First point**
God’s messengers and saints are like sacred lights. Unless the Creator keeps them aflame and shining, no creature’s eyes will be illuminated by their radiance. Unless the Creator creates sight and governs human vision, it is impossible to see the light. So, to see the light—or to know it—we need God’s help and the ability He grants us. At every moment, He must guide, direct and strengthen our reason and thought so that we may perceive the light and benefit from it.
**Second point**
We should not interpret “the Self” in this supplication as “the Essence of God.” God’s Essence is beyond our reach and unknowable—or, in other words, does not need to be known. Creatures need no knowledge in order to be connected with His Essence, for this connection is inherent in their very existence and is sustained by the Creator Himself; the creature plays no part in it.
“God’s Self” can be interpreted, just as “God’s hand” can, as can «عین الله» and «ثار الله» and so on. In fact, “God’s Self” may refer to God’s first sign, which serves as the source and root of His other signs. Until a person knows the source and root of the divine signs, they will not know their branches, leaves and fruit. It is like being unable to receive light from the power grid if one is not connected to it. هو العلیم.....
Thus, we may understand “God’s Self” to mean the first sign, or the primordial manifestation of the Muhammadan Light; the Messenger as the earthly manifestation of that same First Light; and the wali as the Messenger’s secondary manifestation. In other words, by seeking to know the source of the Muhammadan Light, we seek to reach its branches and leaves.
“God’s Self,” “God’s Messenger,” and “God’s wali” are, in fact, expressions for—or different levels of—the sign of the One, All-Powerful God. Although the spirit and soul—the first sign, or the life of God’s signs—are beyond our reach, the body cannot be known without them, even though that same body becomes a sign of the spirit.
In other words, the Self, the Messenger and the wali are “the soul of souls, the soul, and the body.”
Ali علیه السلام is the gate of مدینه النبی, but it was the Messenger of God who knew Ali! We must not separate the gate from the city, or the city from knowledge.
“Knowledge, the City of Knowledge, and the Gate of Knowledge” are, in this sequence, levels of knowledge. Knowledge is like a light that illuminates the city; the city is lit by the light of knowledge; and the Gate of Knowledge is like the eyes, without which we would be deprived of the City of Knowledge and its light.