Greetings. Please advise and guide me regarding the following:
Someone who learns only a handful of technical terms and concepts from the religious sciences, then imagines that knowing them has raised them to a higher rank and made them superior to others, has turned their knowledge into a dark veil and an obstacle to reaching God Almighty. In truth, there is no difference between someone who has learned a few terms such as “the prerequisites of an obligation,” “the conjunction of command and prohibition,” “the primacy of existence,” and “the immutable entities,” and someone who knows a few terms from geology, meteorology, carpentry, or blacksmithing. Neither should be preferred over the other.
How Can Knowledge Become a Dark Veil and Keep Us from Reaching God?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Knowledge that consists merely of technical terms, and leads someone to imagine they have attained a high rank and are superior to others, is a dark veil. A true scholar is one who has attained self-knowledge and piety, and whose knowledge guides them to righteous action. Otherwise, knowledge without action is a burden around one’s neck.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAnyone who specializes in any branch of knowledge or field of learning has their own worth and standing and deserves praise. But a true scholar is one who attains mastery in self-knowledge, the knowledge of piety, and the knowledge of certainty, and reaches the threshold of knowing God.
All branches of knowledge and the arts are children and offshoots of self-knowledge, for every law discovered in this world through the sciences and arts is the result of divine inspiration. Thus, hearts that have been nurtured and awakened attain secrets of knowledge and the arts that people like Newton and Einstein cannot reach—though their own discoveries, too, are due to the flourishing of their souls and hearts.
Merely learning the terminology of the sciences and arts only adds to one’s store of memorized information.
Conceit and self-regard are obstacles to knowledge.
A scholar must be wise; otherwise, his knowledge will become a burden around his neck and add to his ignorance.
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Knowledge is the root of every distinctive spiritual state and the culmination of every lofty station.” That is why the Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “Seeking and acquiring knowledge is obligatory for every Muslim man and woman.” What is meant is knowledge related to piety and the attainment of certainty.
He also said: “Seek knowledge, even in China.” What is meant is knowledge related to self-knowledge, for knowing oneself leads to knowledge of the Almighty Lord.
The Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “Whoever knows himself has surely known his Lord.” You should also take care to learn the kinds of knowledge that help you improve your actions and fulfil your duties correctly. These are the forms of knowledge related to sincerity, without which no deed is sound or accepted.
The Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “I seek refuge in God from an action that is of no benefit.” Such an action is one that is not performed with sincerity, but instead produces a result contrary to it.
Be mindful, too, that a little knowledge calls for much action. Once a person has gained knowledge of something, they must act in accordance with it throughout their life.
Jesus (AS) said: “I saw a stone with the words ‘Turn me over!’ written on it. So I turned it over, and on the other side it said: ‘For one who does not act on his knowledge, acquiring knowledge is an ill omen. What he has learned so far will turn to his detriment, for knowledge that is not matched by action will be a burden to its possessor.’”
The Almighty God revealed to David: “The least I do to a scholar who does not act on his knowledge is to take from his heart the sweetness and delight of remembering Me and communing with Me.” For him, this is more severe than seventy inward punishments.
One should understand that there is no way to journey toward the Almighty God except through knowledge. Unless a person has learned their duties and is familiar with the signs of the way and the particulars of the spiritual journey, they will not be able to travel this path. In worldly life, knowledge is an adornment in outward terms; in its meaning and reality, it leads a person toward Paradise and guides them to the station of the Almighty Lord’s good pleasure.
The true scholar, from whom one should seek guidance, is someone whose righteous, pure and upright deeds, and whose piety, reveal their inner state and spiritual station—not someone who relies on words, debate and disputation, confrontation with others, quarrelling, attacking or making claims. Such things do not reveal a person’s true rank or standing. In former times, those who sought and pursued knowledge were distinguished by reason, worship, modesty, and humility joined with reverent fear. But in our time, people seek knowledge who possess none of these qualities. A scholar needs wisdom, gentleness, kindness, sincerity and purity in conduct, forbearance, patience, generosity in sharing knowledge, and an open hand. A student, too, should have love and eagerness, determination, a free and settled mind, devotion and worship, humility joined with reverent fear, perseverance in fulfilling duties, a good memory, and caution in all matters. These qualities enable a person to succeed in acquiring knowledge and to remain steadfast and resolute on this path.
مصباح الشریعه / translated by Mostafavi،
قال الصادق ع العلم أصل کل حال سنی و منتهى کل منزله رفیعه و لذلک قال النبی ص طلب العلم فریضه على کل مسلم و مسلمه أی علم التقوى و الیقین و قال علی ع اطلبوا العلم و لو بالصین و هو علم معرفه النفس و فیه معرفه الرب عز و جل و قال النبی ص من عرف نفسه فقد عرف ربه ثم علیک من العلم بما لا یصح العمل إلا به و هو الإخلاص قال النبی ص نعوذ بالله من علم لا ینفع و هو العلم الذی یضاد العمل بالإخلاص و اعلم أن قلیل العلم یحتاج إلى کثیر العمل لأن علم ساعه یلزم صاحبه استعماله طول دهره قال عیسى ابن مریم ع رأیت حجرا علیه مکتوب اقلبنی فقلبته فإذا على باطنه مکتوب من لا یعمل بما یعلم مشئوم علیه طلب ما لا یعلم و مردود علیه ما علم أوحى الله تعالى إلى داود ع إن أهون ما أنا صانع بعالم غیر عامل بعلمه أشد من سبعین عقوبه باطنه أن أخرج من قلبه حلاوه ذکری و لیس إلى الله سبحانه طریق یسلک إلا بعلم و العلم زین المرء فی الدنیا و الآخره و سائقه إلى الجنه و به یصل إلى رضوان الله تعالى و العالم حقا هو الذی ینطق عنه أعماله الصالحه و أوراده الزاکیه و صدقه و تقواه لا لسانه و مناظرته و معادلته و تصاوله و دعواه و لقد کان یطلب هذا العلم فی غیر هذا الزمان من کان فیه عقل و نسک و حکمه و حیاء و خشیه و إنا نرى طالبه الیوم من لیس فیه من ذلک شیء و العالم یحتاج إلى عقل و رفق و شفقه و نصح و حلم و صبر و قناعه و بذل و المتعلم یحتاج إلى رغبه و إراده و فراغ و نسک و خشیه و حفظ و حزم
مصباح الشریعه، ص: 13
قال ع عجب المرء بنفسه أحد حساد عقله
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 507