Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2246 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

How Can Two Hadiths on Earning a Living by Teaching Religious Sciences Be Reconciled?

Primary reference: See the answer text 148 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2246

How can we reconcile these two hadiths?
1 ⃣ الإمام الصادق علیه السلام و قد قیل له : هؤلاء یقولون : إن کسب المعلم سحت : کذبوا أعداء الله ، إنما أرادوا أن لا یعلموا القرآن ، و لو أن المعلم أعطاه رجل دیه ولده لکان للمعلم مباحا .حدیث
Imam al-Sadiq (peace be upon him) was told, “Some people say that a teacher’s earnings are unlawful.” He replied, “The enemies of God are lying. They only want to prevent people from teaching the Qur’an. Even if someone were to give a teacher the blood money for his own child [in exchange for instruction], that payment would be lawful and permissible for the teacher.”
2 ⃣عنه صلى الله علیه و آله : تعلموا القرآن و لا تأکلوا به ، و لا تستکبروا به .
The Messenger of God (peace and blessings be upon him and his family) said: “Learn the Qur’an, but do not make it a means of earning your livelihood, and do not use it to vaunt yourselves.”

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

Charging a fee for teaching the Qur’an is forbidden, yet the public treasury is responsible for providing for Qur’an teachers. Anyone who turns religious instruction into a means of making a living is acting reprehensibly. Intention gives shape to our actions, and turning religion into a business is an injustice to religion.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Taking payment for teaching the Qur’an is forbidden, but the public treasury is responsible for providing for the livelihood of the Qur’an teacher.

Anyone who turns religious instruction into a means of trade and a way to earn a living acts reprehensibly and is to be condemned. Likewise, anyone who learns or teaches religion with the aim of making money or pursuing worldly and sensual pleasures is blameworthy.

Intention shapes our actions. Purifying our intention reforms the spirit of our deeds. If religion is turned into a commodity for the sake of earning money, religion itself is wronged.

و قال ع المستأکل بدینه حظه من دینه ما یأکله.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج‏75، ص: 62

Imam Ali «ع»: “...The one who makes religion a means of feeding himself gains from religion only what he consumes.”

عن أبیه عن آبائه ع قال: من قرأ القرآن لیأکل به الناس جاء یوم القیامه و وجهه‏ عظم لا لحم فیه.
ثواب الأعمال و عقاب الأعمال، النص، ص: 280

قال سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول من استأکل بعلمه افتقر فقلت له جعلت فداک إن فی شیعتک و موالیک قوما یتحملون علومکم و یبثونها فی شیعتکم فلا یعدمون على ذلک منهم البر و الصله و الإکرام فقال ع لیس أولئک بمستأکلین إنما المستأکل بعلمه الذی یفتی بغیر علم و لا هدى من الله عز و جل لیبطل به الحقوق طمعا فی حطام الدنیا.
معانی الأخبار، النص، ص: 182

I heard Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام say: “Whoever makes a livelihood out of his knowledge will fall into poverty.” I said, “May I be your ransom! Among your Shia and devoted followers are people who learn your teachings and spread them among your Shia. For doing so, they receive kindness, support and respect from them.” The Imam علیه السلام replied, “These people are not making a livelihood out of their knowledge. The one who does so is a person who issues legal opinions without knowledge or guidance from God, Exalted and Glorious, in order to undermine people’s rights, out of greed for the fleeting goods of this world.”

عن الفضل بن أبی قره قال: قلت لأبی عبد الله ع هؤلاء یقولون إن کسب المعلم سحت فقال کذبوا أعداء الله إنما أرادوا أن لا یعلموا القرآن لو أن المعلم أعطاه رجل دیه ولده لکان للمعلم مباحا.
وسائل الشیعه، ج‏17، ص: 155

Hassan, the teacher, says: “I asked Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام about teaching [the Qur’an]. The Imam علیه السلام said, ‘Do not take payment for teaching [the Qur’an].’
“I asked, ‘May I make an agreement to teach poetry, writing letters and the like?’
“The Imam علیه السلام replied, ‘Yes, provided that all the children you teach are treated equally and you do not give some precedence over others.’”

Jurrah al-Mada’ini relates that Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام said:
“A teacher does not teach for a fee, but if he is given a gift, he may accept it.”

Ishaq ibn Ammar says: “I told Imam Musa ibn Ja‘far علیهما السلام, ‘We have a neighbor who teaches reading and writing. He has asked me to inquire of you about his work.’ The Imam علیه السلام said, ‘Tell him that whenever a child is entrusted to him, he should tell the child’s family: “I will teach him writing and arithmetic, and I will teach him the Qur’an for the sake of God’s reward,” so that his income may be lawful.’”

In Man la yahduruhu al-faqih, it is related that the Commander of the Faithful علیه السلام said: “Whoever receives payment for teaching the Qur’an will have no reward beyond that payment in the Hereafter.”

منابع فقه شیعه (ترجمه جامع أحادیث الشیعه)، ج‏22، ص: 527

In Fiqh al-Rida, it is related:
“‘Abd Allah ibn Mas‘ud came to the Prophet صلى الله عليه و آله and said, ‘O Messenger of God صلى الله عليه و آله! So-and-so, a Bedouin, gave me a camel and its calf.’
“The Prophet صلى الله عليه و آله asked, ‘Why, Ibn Mas‘ud?’
“He replied, ‘Because I taught him four surahs of the Qur’an.’
“The Prophet صلى الله عليه و آله said, ‘Give them back to him, Ibn Mas‘ud, for payment for the Qur’an is forbidden.’”

Fiqh al-Rida also states:
“Know that a teacher’s fee is forbidden if he makes an agreement to teach the Qur’an. The fee of a teacher who teaches nothing but the Qur’an is forbidden, whether or not he stipulates payment.”

Fiqh al-Rida also relates: “Regarding the verse ‘They consume much that is forbidden,’ Ibn ‘Abbas is reported to have said: ‘This refers to the fees of teachers who make agreements to teach the Qur’an.’”

Fadl ibn Abi Qurra says: “I told Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام, ‘They say that a teacher’s income is forbidden.’
“The Imam علیه السلام replied, ‘The enemies of God are lying. They only want people not to teach the Qur’an. If a man gives the teacher [of the Qur’an] the blood money for his child, it is lawful for the teacher.’”

It is related from Fadl ibn Abi Qurra that he said to Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام: “They say that a teacher’s income is forbidden!” The Imam علیه السلام replied, “The enemies of God are lying. They only want people not to teach their children the Qur’an. If someone gives the teacher the blood money for his child, it is lawful for the teacher.”

In Manaqib Ibn Shahrashub, it is related that ‘Abd al-Rahman al-Sulami taught Surah al-Fatiha to one of Imam Husayn’s children. When the child recited the surah to the Imam علیه السلام, he gave the teacher a thousand dinars and a thousand robes, and filled his mouth with gold. When someone objected to the Imam علیه السلام about this, he replied, “How could these gifts compare with the value of his teaching?”

In ‘Awali, it is related that the Prophet صلى الله عليه و آله said:
“The most deserving thing for which you may receive payment is the Book of God.”

Qutaybah al-A‘sha says: “I told Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام, ‘I recite the Qur’an, and then people bring me gifts. May I accept them?’
“The Imam علیه السلام replied, ‘No.’
“I said, ‘I do not stipulate any payment.’
“The Imam علیه السلام said, ‘Tell me: if you did not recite the Qur’an, would they bring you gifts?’
“I said, ‘No.’
“The Imam علیه السلام replied, ‘Then do not accept them!’”

The late Shaykh al-Tusi قدس سره interpreted this hadith as indicating that such acceptance is disliked.

منابع فقه شیعه (ترجمه جامع أحادیث الشیعه)، ج‏22، ص: 529

Jurrah al-Mada’ini says: “Imam al-Sadiq علیه السلام forbade a Qur’an reciter from receiving a fee when he would not recite without an agreed payment.”

And in the hadith collection Ja‘fariyyat, we read the following from Imam ‘Ali علیه السلام: “The fee of a Qur’an reciter who will not recite without payment is forbidden; but there is nothing wrong with providing for him from the public treasury.”

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022