Excuse me, استاد. Regarding the twelve Mahdis mentioned in the traditions, some reports identify them as our Imams, while others describe the twelve Mahdis as people who will come after the Mahdi. How should we reconcile these reports? Here are two examples. Thank you.
Shaykh Ṣadūq (may God have mercy on him) relates through his chain of transmission that Imam Husayn (AS) said:
«منا اثنا عشر مهدیا او لهم امیر المؤمنین علی بن ابیطالب و آخر هم التاسع من ولدی و هو الامام القائم بالحق یحیی الله به الارض بعد موتها و تظهر به دین الحق علی الدین کله و لو کره المشرکون له غیبه یرتد فیها اقوام و یثبت علی الدین آخرون فیؤذون و یقال لهم متی هذا الوعدان کنتم صادقین اما ان الصابر فی غیبته علی الاذی و التکذیب کالمجاهد بالسیف بین یدی رسول الله صلی الله علیه و آله .»
“There are twelve Mahdis from among us. The first is the Commander of the Faithful, Ali ibn Abi Talib, and the last is the ninth of my descendants. He is the Imam who will rise in truth. Through him, God will bring the earth back to life after its death, and through him will make the true religion prevail over every religion, even though the polytheists may dislike it. He will have an occultation during which some people will turn away from the faith, while others will remain steadfast in it. They will be persecuted and told, ‘If you are truthful, when will this promise be fulfilled?’ Be aware that whoever patiently endures persecution and denial during his occultation is like one who fights with a sword at the side of the Messenger of God.”
عَن أبی بصیر قال: قلت للصادق جعفر بن محمد ع یا ابن رسول الله إنی سمعت من أبیک ع أنه قال یکون بعد القائم اثنا عشر مهدیا فقال إنما قال اثنا عشر مهدیا و لم یقل اثنا عشر إماما و لکنهم قوم من شیعتنا یدعون الناس إلى موالاتنا و معرفه حقنا.
Abu Basir relates: “I said to al-Sadiq, Ja‘far ibn Muhammad (AS), ‘O son of the Messenger of God, I heard your father say that after al-Qa’im there will be twelve Mahdis.’ He replied, ‘My father said there would be twelve Mahdis; he did not say twelve Imams. They are a group of our Shi‘a who call people to love us and to recognize our rights.’”
*Kamal al-Din wa Tamam al-Ni‘ma*, vol. 2, p. 358.
*Bihar al-Anwar*, 51/133, hadith 4.