Skip to content

notifications_active Weekly Meshkat-e Noor Session: Thursdays at 20:30 at Haj Reza Mosque

languageEN
فارسیEnglishالعربية
login Login
Question No. 2549 31 August 2022 Official answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat) verified Content level: Intermediate

How Did the Imams’ Knowledge of the Unseen Differ Before and During Their Imamate?

Primary reference: See the answer text 36 views 23 explanatory notes and annotations
Verified answer Documented and evidence-based
Dear questioner, Master Ali Saei
Tracking code: #Q-2549

… [Forwarded from Ya Ali]

Greetings,

It should be noted that there was some confusion in the way the point was explained and presented. You treated Imam Ali (peace be upon him) as having the same access to knowledge of the unseen when he was not Imam as when he was Imam, but that is not correct. On Laylat al-Mabit, Imam Ali was not yet Imam and did not have access to the knowledge that is a prerogative of the Imamate. Your view is correct in that regard. But once the infallible Imams assume the Imamate, they possess this knowledge, though they are not commissioned to act on the knowledge of the unseen.

Perhaps this is difficult to explain and understand. The best example may be the story of Prophet Moses and Khidr in the verses of Surah al-Kahf: Khidr was commissioned to act in the realm of creation, while Prophet Moses was commissioned to act in the realm of religious law.

Consider Imam Hussein’s words and actions throughout the epic of Karbala. At every moment, the Imam acts rationally, without being swayed by emotion or feeling. Even in the most difficult moments—when anyone’s emotions would be stirred—this noble man masters his feelings and does nothing irrational that would harm religion or humanity. The Imam’s conduct points to his knowledge of the unseen, his insight into the future and the consequences of his actions, and the promise that truth will triumph over falsehood. It makes clear that the Imam sees all future events. He advises Umar ibn Sa‘d not to set his hopes on the promise of the governorship of Rayy, telling him: “You will not even be able to eat the wheat of Rayy.” These words of the Imam show his knowledge of the unseen.

#Reply2549_Page_Three

Before his Imamate on earth began, Ali, the Commander of the Faithful (peace be upon him), was God’s wali on earth and held wilayah by God’s authority. Undoubtedly, his Imamate marked the beginning of a particular responsibility, not the beginning of his station and rank.

Do all those verses about his virtues refer to the period before his Imamate?

Ali’s access to the unseen, by God’s permission, knows no bounds!

أرى نور الوحی و الرساله و أشم ریح النبوه

Ali (peace be upon him): “I saw the light of revelation and the message, and sensed the fragrance of prophethood!”

By God’s will and in keeping with His wisdom, the prophets and the awliya of God may be granted knowledge of the divine unseen, or that knowledge may remain hidden from them. According to the report of the Commander of the Faithful himself, from the very beginning of the Messenger of God’s mission, he was his companion in revelation and the message, and in knowledge of the unseen and the manifest. The beauty of Laylat al-Mabit may lie all the more in the fact that, in keeping with divine wisdom, Ali was not aware of the outcome, so that the beauty of his blessed defense would be revealed to all creation and his offering of his life to the Beloved made manifest.

Even if he had known the outcome, then, in accordance with the principle that capacity must be proportionate to what it contains, the bearer of the unseen would have been capable of bearing what was entrusted to him. He would have acted in a way befitting one entrusted with a trust, appearing as though he had no access to the unseen, so that his rank as one who gives himself for the Messenger of Truth might be established.

It is unfair to describe Imam Hussein’s conduct simply as rational, for he is reason itself. In other words, the Messenger of God is the source and root of reason, and the Imams—including Imam Hussein—are its branches. The Messenger of God is the sun of reason, the Imams its moons, and God’s other servants are nourished by the rays of those same moons.

Emotions and feelings, too, are among the vistas of the Imams’ souls. The Imams themselves are, so to speak, God’s knowledge of the unseen and the manifest. To speak of access to the unseen is, in reality, to enter the Imams’ sacred and magnificent domain.

We must rebuild our understanding of the Ahl al-Bayt (peace be upon them).

The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)

The infallible Imams’ knowledge of the unseen during their imamate came by God’s permission. Before then, however, and on the night of Laylat al-Mabit, Imam Ali (AS) did not know the unseen, so that the beauty of his self-sacrifice could be fully revealed. Imam Hussein’s (AS) actions at Karbala, too, were guided by pure reason and knowledge of the future: he warned Umar ibn Sa‘d against eating the wheat of Rayy.

Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)

Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural Center

Question 2549-2:

… [Forwarded from یاعلی]
Greetings,

It should be pointed out that there was some confusion in how the matter was explained and presented.

You explained حضرت علی ع as having the same knowledge of the unseen before he was Imam as he had when he was Imam, and that is not correct. On ليلة المبیت, علی ع was not Imam and did not have access to the knowledge that is a means of exercising the Imamate. Your view is correct in that regard. But during their Imamate, the infallible Imams have knowledge, though they are not charged with acting on knowledge of the unseen.

Perhaps this is difficult to explain and understand, but the best example is the story of حضرت موسی ع and حضرت خضر ع in the verses of Surah al-Kahf. حضرت خضر had a mission in the realm of creation, while حضرت موسی ع’s mission concerned religious law.

Pay close attention to the words of امام حسین علیه السلام at every moment of the epic of Karbala. At every turn, Imam ع acted rationally, without being carried away by emotion or feeling. Even in the hardest moments, when anyone’s emotions might have been stirred, this noble man mastered his feelings and did nothing irrational that would cause harm in terms of religion or humanity. Imam ع’s conduct points to his knowledge of the unseen, his foresight, and his awareness of the outcome of his actions and of the promise that truth would triumph over falsehood. It makes clear that the Imam sees all future events. He advises عمر سعد not to put his faith in the promise of the governorship of Rayy, and the Imam’s words show his knowledge of the unseen when he says: “You, عمر سعد, will not even be able to eat the wheat of Rayy.”

🌸🔆🌷بسم الله الرحمن الرحیم🌷🔆🌸
#Answer2549_Page_Three
🍀🔅🌷Peace be upon you too🌷🔅🍀
🌷🔅🌱Ali, أميرالمؤمنين علیه السلام, was God’s ولیّ on earth even before his Imamate began; he was entrusted with divine authority by God. Without a doubt, his Imamate marked the beginning of a particular responsibility on earth, not the beginning of his special rank and station.
🌷🔅🌱Do all those verses that speak of the Imam’s virtues refer to the period before his Imamate began?
Ali علیه السلام’s insight into the unseen (by God’s permission) knows no bounds!
أَرَى نُورَ الْوَحْيِ وَ الرِّسَالَةِ وَ أَشُمُّ رِيحَ النُّبُوَّة
Ali علیه السلام: “I saw the light of revelation and messengership, and tasted the fragrance of prophethood!”
🌷🔅🌱At God’s will and by divine wisdom, the prophets and friends of God are either granted knowledge of the divine unseen or kept from it. According to the Master’s own account, from the very beginning of the Messenger of God’s mission, رسول اکرم صلی الله علیه و آله و سلم, he was the companion of revelation and messengership, and of knowledge of the unseen and the manifest. The greater beauty of ليلة المبیت lies in the possibility that, in keeping with divine wisdom, he was not aware of the outcome, so that the beauty of his blessed defense might be revealed to all, and his giving his life for the Beloved made manifest.

Even if he did know the outcome, by virtue of the principle of capacity and the fit between vessel and contents, the bearer of the unseen would be worthy of what he bore, and would conduct himself with the integrity expected of a trustworthy bearer. His state would be like that of someone with no insight into the unseen, so that his degree of self-sacrifice for the Messenger of Truth might be established.
🌷🔅🌱It is unfair to describe the conduct of حضرت امام حسین علیه السلام as merely rational, for he is pure intellect. In other words, the Messenger of God is the source and root of intellect, and the Imams, including امام حسین علیه السلام, are its branches. Put another way, the Messenger of God ص is the sun of intellect, the Imams its moons, and the other servants of God are nourished by the light of those moons.
🌷🔅🌱Emotions and feelings, too, are among the dimensions of the souls of the Imams علیهم السلام! The Imams themselves are, so to speak, God’s knowledge of the unseen and the manifest. In truth, the question of insight into the unseen is a matter of entering the Imams’ exalted sanctuary.
🌷🔅🌱We must renew the way we understand the اهل بیت علیهم السلام.

Did you find this answer illuminating? Your feedback helps us refine our responses and organize future sessions.
Audio attachment: This question currently has no audio file; the answer is provided in written form, with supporting arguments.

Related questions

Official answers
Question #3100
How Can Food-Based Sorcery Be Undone?
Critique of Doubts • 31 August 2022
Question #1842
What Is Meant by the Prophet’s Hadith About Lady Fatima’s Cloak (SA)?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 20 August 2022
Question #272
Why Is Imam Husayn (AS) Known as the Son of Sidrat al-Muntaha?
Ahl al-Bayt and Islamic History • 17 July 2022
Question #3099
How Can We Visit the House of God from Afar?
Jurisprudence and Rulings • 31 August 2022