Regarding the identification of individuals as fulfilling signs mentioned in the narrations, how likely is it that such identifications are correct? And if identifying people in this way is unreliable, why did the Infallibles (peace be upon them) give these signs?
For example, identifying particular individuals as Sayyid al-Khurasani or Sayyid al-Yamani.
How likely is it that the signs of the Mahdi’s advent apply to particular individuals?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Identifying particular individuals as fulfilling the signs of the Mahdi’s advent must be done carefully and by specialists. Emotional, hasty identifications can dishearten believers and pave the way for deviation. False claimants and unfounded identifications are themselves among the signs of the age of the Mahdi’s advent; discerning the truth is a matter for those qualified to do so.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterEvery branch of knowledge has its own specialists. Gold assayers are experts at distinguishing the genuine from the counterfeit; scholars, sages and genuine researchers are experts at discerning the signs of the reappearance and matching them to their true manifestations. Any emotional or hasty attempt to make such a match discourages believers and may even make them indifferent to the genuine signs. It also creates an opening for the enemy’s schemes to divert people’s attention from the matter of the reappearance.
False claimants and mistaken identifications are themselves among the signs of the era of the reappearance! It is by the truth that its people must be recognized. Adorning oneself with piety is the key to recognizing the people of piety and the diamonds of the end times; otherwise, these supposed shards of glass will claim the place of diamonds. What do Sayyid al-Yamani and the like have in common with false claimants?!