In light of this saying of the Commander of the Faithful: Nahj al-Balagha, 248 — و قال ( علیه السلام ) : من ظن بک خیرا فصدق ظنه
If this good opinion is unfounded, and the person himself knows that it is not true, should he still affirm it? Would that not be considered a lie? Also, if humility is the guiding principle, would affirming someone’s good opinion of us not amount to arrogance? Or does it mean that we should bring our conduct closer to that good opinion?
If a Good Opinion Is Unfounded, Should It Be Affirmed?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
If we have no evidence that someone harbours ill intentions and are confident that he is not corrupt, the default is to affirm his favourable opinion of himself until he strives to prove it. This affirmation opens the way to friendship, but it does not mean entrusting him with all our affairs and secrets; we must still guard ourselves and our secrets.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhen we have no evidence that someone harbors ill will, and are confident that they are not corrupt, we should, as a rule, take them at their word. This will encourage the person in question to demonstrate and express their good opinion, and to keep the other party from losing trust in them.
Such affirmation opens the way to friendship. But believing someone does not mean handing over all our affairs and secrets to them. We each have responsibilities toward ourselves: we must guard ourselves and our secrets, act judiciously when forming relationships, and avoid being indiscriminately open.