You said that when two people who are not mahrams chat, a person’s thoughts alone can be a source of arousal. If one controls one’s thoughts, does the soul come under control as well, or is the soul also directly involved? When thoughts are controlled, does that mean Satan has been deprived of the means to tempt us? If those means are taken away from Satan, is the soul still at risk?
If One Controls One’s Thoughts, Is It Still Problematic for Two Non-Mahrams to Communicate in an Open Online Space?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Satan’s presence in online spaces is real: he works on a person’s heart and soul, not their body. Sin, and the desire to sin, arise within a person; the sense of privacy in online spaces can intensify them. It is therefore best to avoid all unnecessary online interactions with a non-mahram, since Satan urges people toward sexual immorality and lust, and makes them seem attractive.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterSatan is truly present even in spaces that are merely virtual. His work is with the human heart and soul, not the body!
It is human intentions that give actions their spirit. Sin and the desire to sin arise within a person, and in virtual spaces this state is intensified by the sense of privacy.
و أما الأعور فهو صاحب الزنا یأمر به و یزینه
شرح أصول الکافی (صدرا)، ج1، ص: 247
And as for al-A‘war, he is responsible for adultery: he commands it and makes it seem attractive!
In other words, Satan has a department devoted to adultery and lust, with al-A‘war as its minister. Through special networks and organisations, it devises specific plans to foster obscenity and corruption.
Let us not forget that all human desires are spiritual in nature: even without bodily organs, people can fulfil their psychological and carnal desires.
Therefore, one must avoid any unnecessary virtual interactions with non-mahrams.