Supplement 2722
You said that estrangement weakens affection and mercy. If someone has previously tried reducing the offender's privileges and it produced no result, what should they do now? Please explain.
If reducing privileges did not work, what should be done to reform the offender?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
In dealing with an offender, after a fair judgment, if reducing privileges has not produced results, one should act with divine grace and generosity. Forgiveness is the best and most lasting punishment, and one should not act hastily or impose punishment according to one's own personal opinion. Discovering the most beautiful response brings with it God's good pleasure.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterEvery action and response should follow a fair judgment. Any error in judgment increases the likelihood of an unjust response. In most cases, we should show grace and generosity rather than simply enforce justice; finding the most beautiful response will bring the pleasure of the Merciful God.
Even if it is established that the person we are addressing is at fault, it is not right to resort to other means as long as there is still room for admonition and counsel.
Forgiveness is the most effective form of punishment, with the greatest and most lasting impact.
In any case, we should not punish someone hastily or on the basis of our own personal judgment.