Hello, sir, and Zolal Akhtaran,
No historical report or account can produce certainty—not even a mutawātir report, regardless of whether the number of transmitters exceeds five or reaches five hundred. Advances in historical scholarship have made clear that neither the number of reports nor the number of people transmitting them can establish a report’s certainty. Some scholars of legal theory have argued that a mutawātir report is certain because collusion among its transmitters is unlikely, but this is not a sound argument. What matters is how many people witnessed an event, not how many people later transmitted an account of it. A report transmitted by five men, five women, five Shiites, five Sunnis and five non-Muslims carries greater weight than a mutawātir report transmitted by five hundred Twelver Shiites. That is why some scholars of legal theory have said that a mutawātir report yields only theoretical knowledge, and why Shahid Sadr regards the certainty it produces as inductive rather than inferential.
In any case, we should remember that it was precisely Akhbārism that eclipsed reason and brought Muslim society down into humiliation.