A contradiction in an exegetical narration
If God’s hidden knowledge—which is not subject to badaʾ—is the same as Umm al-Kitab, would that not invalidate the narration stating that “لعلی حکیم” in the verse “و انه فی ام الکتاب لدینا لعلی حکیم” refers to Imam Ali (AS)? The assumption, after all, is that the custodians of knowledge come after the stage of ratification!
If Umm al-Kitab is the concealed knowledge, is the narration “لعلی حکیم” thereby invalidated?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
If Umm al-Kitab is God’s hidden knowledge, which is not subject to badaʾ, does that invalidate the narration identifying “لعلی حکیم” in the verse “وإنه فی أم الکتاب لدینا لعلی حکیم” with Imam Ali? The Infallibles (AS), including our master Ali (AS), are God’s hidden book and the arena of divine badaʾ, though divine wisdom may mean they are not aware of all their own mysteries.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAs noted, the Infallibles علیهم السلام, including Mawla Ali علیه السلام, are the hidden Book of God and the arena of divine badaʾ—even if, as divine wisdom requires, this Mother of the Book is not aware of itself! الله اعلم!