With regard to the statement, “Every definitive matter descends from heaven, and the definitive cannot be two things; it can only be one. Therefore, whoever rules in a way that gives rise to disagreement, his ruling is the ruling of God, the Almighty and Exalted. And whoever issues a ruling in which there is disagreement, yet considers himself to be right, has ruled according to ṭāghūt (falsehood),” laws and rulings are sometimes changed because people lack knowledge or have only limited understanding at a given time. As human knowledge advances, people may come to understand certain matters more fully after many years. Would this kind of change in the law also be considered ṭāghūt?
Is Changing Laws on the Basis of Human Knowledge an Instance of Ṭāghūt?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Scientific progress is wise only when knowledge is guided by reason; otherwise, every advance in knowledge will add to ignorance. Knowledge that brings about evil instead of good—for example, medical progress that has led to more illness, or technologies that have increased human suffering—is an instance of ṭāghūt.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterOnly عبد الحکیم performs wise deeds.
Acting wisely is a sign of nearness to God and servitude. Anyone who loses the path of servitude will find their actions feeble, foolish and full of error!
Scientific progress is wise only when knowledge is guided by reason (reason understood as the guide to noble virtues). Otherwise, every kind of scientific progress will only add to ignorance—like a light that blinds. The advancement of science in today’s society has increased ignorance, heedlessness and sin. Knowledge that, instead of bringing good, has become a means of harm: medical science, for example, has not reduced illness but has accelerated its spread; and other human technologies have added to people’s suffering and hardship. The matter of killing and slaughter has its own place!