Dear Professor, during session 167 of *Tadabbur in the Qur’an*, on verse 1 of Surah al-Tahrim, you mistakenly referred to the Prophet عليهم السلام. Since Mr. Jabbarian had previously answered Your Excellency’s question on this topic, he forwarded the exchange to the group. You had some criticisms of the question and answer; please respond.
[Forwarded from Dua]
Hello. The Prophet’s action seems more like an act of greater caution than a mistake.
[Forwarded from Saeed Hasanzadeh Delgosha]
Hello.
In that case, he should have been praised, not reprimanded!
[Forwarded from Dua]
This is not a reprimand; it is a question and answer between God and the Prophet. Does God’s asking the Prophet a question mean that He has reprimanded him?
[Forwarded from Saeed Hasanzadeh Delgosha]
يا أیها الذین آمنوا لا تحرموا طیبات ما أحل الله لکم ولا تعتدوا ۚ إن الله لا یحب المعتدین [سوره المائده : 87]
Dua, [14.02.18 07:18]
[Forwarded from Saeed Hasanzadeh Delgosha]
If no mistake was made, then “غفور” at the end of the verse under discussion is a pointless and irrelevant word. Moreover, expiation—which is mentioned in the following verse—is by its very nature intended to cover an error or mistake; if no error was made, the obligation of expiation makes no sense.