Can we not clearly infer from this hadith in Imam Khomeini’s Forty Hadith—which apparently comes from Chapter 11 of Shaykh al-Saduq’s Tawhid—that the attributes are identical with the essence? Is there any need for you or me to interpret it otherwise?
Is God’s Knowledge Identical with His Essence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
God’s knowledge is identical with His essence and is free of all ignorance. Nothing is hidden from Him; all His creations are manifest to Him. His knowledge depends on no object of knowledge. Divine attributes such as knowledge, hearing, and sight are His primordial creations, and their relation to His essence is that of creator to created.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterKnowledge itself: This means that His incomparable Essence is free of all ignorance. Nothing is hidden from Him; beings not yet brought into existence are already clear and manifest to Him. What is referred to as creation is, in reality, a manifestation of divine knowledge: knowledge makes itself manifest, and the known becomes a sign of divine knowledge.
Allah, Exalted and Almighty, needs no attribute in order to know, hear, or see.
سمعت أبا عبد الله ع یقول لم یزل الله عز و جل ربنا و العلم ذاته و لا معلوم و السمع ذاته و لا مسموع و البصر ذاته و لا مبصر و القدره ذاته و لا مقدور فلما أحدث الأشیاء و کان المعلوم وقع العلم منه على المعلوم و السمع على المسموع و البصر على المبصر و القدره على المقدور قال قلت فلم یزل الله متحرکا قال فقال تعالى الله عن ذلک إن الحرکه صفه محدثه بالفعل قال قلت فلم یزل الله متکلما قال فقال إن الکلام صفه محدثه لیست بأزلیه کان الله عز و جل و لا متکلم.
Al-Kafi (Islamic edition), vol. 1, p. 107. Al-Kulayni, Muhammad ibn Ya‘qub ibn Ishaq, 8 volumes, Dar al-Kutub al-Islamiyya, Tehran, fourth edition, 1407 AH.
Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “Allah, Exalted and Almighty, our Lord, has always existed. Knowledge was His Essence, though there was nothing known; hearing was His Essence, though there was nothing heard; sight was His Essence, though there was nothing seen; and power was His Essence, though there was nothing within its power. Then, when He brought things into being and the known came to exist, His knowledge came to bear upon the known, His hearing upon what was heard, His sight upon what was seen, and His power upon what was within its power.”
Abu Basir said, “I asked, ‘Has God, then, always been in motion?’” The Imam replied, “God is exalted above that. Motion is an attribute that comes into being through an act.”
Abu Basir said, “I asked, ‘Has God, then, always been speaking?’” He replied, “Speech is an attribute that comes into being; it is neither eternal nor everlasting. Allah, Exalted and Almighty, existed, and there was no speaker.”
أنى یکون یعلم و لا معلوم
The All-Knowing God does not need an instrument of knowledge in order to know; the word «یعلم» is like «یخلق».
Hadiths that explain other hadiths: the hadith «... لم یزل الله عز و جل ربنا و العلم ذاته و لا معلوم...» explains the hadith «... أنى یکون یعلم و لا معلوم...».
عن حماد بن عیسى قال: سألت أبا عبد الله ع فقلت لم یزل الله یعلم قال أنى یکون یعلم و لا معلوم قال قلت فلم یزل الله یسمع قال أنى یکون ذلک و لا مسموع قال قلت فلم یزل یبصر قال أنى یکون ذلک و لا مبصر قال ثم قال لم یزل الله علیما سمیعا بصیرا ذات علامه سمیعه بصیره.
Al-Tawhid (al-Saduq), p. 139. Ibn Babawayh, Muhammad ibn Ali, 1 volume, Society of Seminary Teachers, Iran, Qom, first edition, 1398 AH.
Hammad ibn Isa said: “I asked Imam al-Sadiq (AS), ‘Has God always known?’ He replied, ‘How could He know when there was nothing known?’ I asked, ‘Then has He always heard?’ He replied, ‘How could that be when there was nothing heard?’ I asked, ‘Then has He always seen?’ He replied, ‘How could that be when there was nothing visible, nothing seen?’ Then he said, ‘God has always been knowing, hearing, and seeing: an Essence that is supremely knowing, hearing, and seeing.’”
Careful consideration of the hadith above establishes the oneness of the Essence, which is independent of attributes: the Real Essence needs no attribute or instrument in order to know, hear, or see.
If we mistakenly say that knowledge is one of His essential attributes, we can no longer say that hearing is also His Essence, since knowledge, being the Essence of Allah, would leave no place for His hearing. The same would apply to sight and all His other conceivable attributes. Alternatively, we might say that knowledge, hearing, sight, and so on are one and the same, and that only the wording differs. In that case, the truth established is that knowledge, hearing, sight, and so on are not attributes at all, but rather names for His self-sufficient Essence.
Unless His knowledge manifests itself in relation to something not yet known, there can be nothing known. In reality, there was nothing known, but Allah, the All-Knowing, made it known. This is like creation: until the Creator wills it, there is no creature. The Creator willed, and the creature came into being. Allah willed, and what was heard came into being; Allah willed, and what was seen came into being.
The hadith thus suggests that Allah brought the known into being by the will of His knowledge, what was heard by the will of His hearing, what was seen by the will of His sight, and what was within His power by the will of His power.
Another way to put it is that the attribute of His infinite knowledge leaves no place for the attributes of hearing, sight, or any of His other qualities. In the same way, a single infinite attribute would have no place alongside His infinite Essence. For the sake of clarity, we should say that He wills as He chooses, whether it be the will of knowledge, hearing, or sight: whatever His will is directed toward comes into being.
But the Real Essence is free of motion, for motion is the striving of a deficient thing to reach a place where it was not before; it bespeaks need and limitation. A tree begins to move toward its desired perfection as it grows; this course of movement, change, and transformation points to deficiency, weakness, and lack. The Real Essence is exalted above every kind of motion. He is the One who creates motion and is beyond all motion. He encompasses all things and has inherent dominion over them. No thing is independent of His incomparable Essence; rather, all who are in need turn toward His mighty threshold.
God brings to pass whatever He wills. The coming to be known of what is known, heard of what is heard, and seen of what is seen depends solely on His will. But His knowledge, hearing, and sight do not depend on what is known, heard, or seen. Whatever is to be known, He knew before it became known; before it could be heard, He was hearing it; and before it could be seen, He was seeing it.
How this is possible lies beyond the limited understanding of His needy creatures. Creation is a realm of poverty and need, and our thoughts and understanding arise from this very source of poverty and need. But the Being at whose threshold poverty and need have no place knows all things, whether they have appeared on the stage of time or not.
Supplement: #Question1543