Is it permissible to prostrate at the blessed tombs of the Imams, peace be upon them, out of respect for their sacred presence? And would this prostration, as some people say, count as prostration toward God?
Is it permissible to prostrate at the Imams’ tombs out of respect?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Prostration is for God alone and belongs to God alone. Prostrating at the tombs of the Imams, peace be upon them, without divine permission is considered shirk. To give thanks in the presence of a sacred shrine, it is better to offer a prayer of gratitude or prostrate somewhere that will not be misunderstood by ordinary people or give the Wahhabis an excuse.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe revered figures are themselves the very embodiment of prostration, and accept not the slightest idolatrous disrespect.
The expression سجده ی الی الله is broad and open to different interpretations. What we should say is that prostration belongs to God alone, is for God alone, and is offered to God alone. Prostration is the most beautiful sign of servitude to God. We do not know the form or manner of the angels’ prostration before Adam or of Joseph’s brothers’ prostration before the Prophet Joseph علیه السلام. But since God’s command and permission were involved, their act was an expression of obedience to God’s command and did not conflict with the oneness of worship.
But what is the intention of those who prostrate before the shrines of the revered figures علیهم السلام?
Does a servant prostrate before one beloved by God in order to draw nearer to God?
Has such a ruling been issued by the Sacred Lawgiver?
During their earthly lives, the revered figures did not permit anyone to prostrate before them. Did they grant their followers permission to prostrate before their blessed tombs?
Is prostration at a tomb, like the angels’ prostration before Adam, an act of reverence toward a friend of God and worshipful obedience to God? If so, God Himself would have had to issue this command. Does such an instruction exist???
إن الشرک أخفى من دبیب النمل- على صفاه سوداء فی لیله ظلماء
In the realm of worship, a person can unwittingly become tainted by shirk. Does prostrating at a shrine or before a blessed tomb not make one even more tainted by shirk??? And all this under the pretext that prostration «toward God» is permissible as an expression of tawhid.
Rationalising an idolatrous act does not cleanse it of shirk; dressing it up only emboldens people to do it. No one can associate anything with God in the hope of drawing nearer to Him. There is no sin committed for the sake of drawing near to God! Dressing up an idolatrous act is one of Satan’s great stratagems, deceptions, and snares. Prostration to anyone other than God—without God’s permission, as in the angels’ prostration before Adam or Joseph’s brothers’ prostration before the Prophet Joseph علیه السلام—is an act of shirk.
If someone wishes to offer thanks for the privilege of visiting the sacred shrine, let them do so beautifully: let them pray a prayer of gratitude in that holy place, and prostrate for longer before the God of the Imams and of all existence, so that they may perform the best and most beautiful act and earn the pleasure of God, His Messenger, and the friends of God.
If someone intends, in the presence of the sacred shrine, to perform a prostration of gratitude for being granted the privilege of visiting that exalted place, then—even if they themselves are fully aware of every aspect of the matter—it would be better to perform this prostration somewhere else. That way, ordinary people will not misunderstand it, take it as a model for themselves despite its improper intention, and imitate it. It will also avoid providing people such as the Wahhabis with an excuse to attack the Shiites.