Is it true that the Infallible Ones (AS) are effaced in the Essence of God Most High, or is this mistaken?
Is It True That the Infallible Ones (AS) Are Effaced in God’s Essence?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
The Infallible Ones (AS) are regarded as the Most Beautiful Names of God, and the Names are distinct from the Divine Essence. Every created being is nothing before the peerless Essence of the Lord, but this does not mean that creatures are one with the Essence. Rather, it points to the creature’s limitations before the infinite Creator. The Divine Essence is beyond all deficiency or increase, and creatures are nothing in comparison with it.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterThe Infallible Ones, peace be upon them, are as the Most Beautiful Names of the incomparable Essence of the Almighty Lord. The Names are distinct from the Essence: they are only signs and indications, created by God—creations that serve as means for the other creations of the Lord, the Originator and Innovator.
When the Lord creates a creature, He brings what was not into being; He grants existence to what did not exist. In reality, whether a creature exists or not makes no difference to the Lord’s Essence. Neither state rises above it nor impinges upon it. In other words, every creature is utterly effaced before the Essence of the Real. And among all creatures, the Divine Names acknowledge this manifest truth.
This is the very truth expressed in the hadith:
الحمد لله الذی لم تسبق له حال حالا فیکون أولا قبل أن یکون آخرا و یکون ظاهرا قبل أن یکون باطنا کل مسمى بالوحده غیره قلیل و کل عزیز غیره ذلیل و کل قوی غیره ضعیف و کل مالک غیره مملوک و کل عالم غیره متعلم و کل قادر غیره یقدر و یعجز و کل سمیع غیره یصم عن لطیف الأصوات و یصمه کبیرها و یذهب عنه ما بعد منها و کل بصیر غیره یعمى عن خفی الألوان و لطیف الأجسام و کل ظاهر غیره [غیر باطن] باطن و کل باطن غیره غیر ظاهر لم یخلق ما خلقه لتشدید سلطان و لا تخوف من عواقب زمان و لا استعانه على ند مثاور و لا شریک مکاثر و لا ضد منافر و لکن خلائق مربوبون و عباد داخرون لم یحلل فی الأشیاء فیقال هو [فیها] کائن و لم ینأ عنها فیقال هو منها بائن لم یؤده خلق ما ابتدأ و لا تدبیر ما ذرأ و لا وقف به عجز عما خلق و لا ولجت علیه شبهه فیما قضى و قدر بل قضاء متقن و علم محکم و أمر مبرم المأمول مع النقم المرهوب مع النعم
Nahj al-Balagha (ed. Subhi al-Salih), p. 96
Praise be to God, whom no state has preceded another, so that He might be first before being last, or manifest before being hidden. Whatever is called one besides Him is few; whatever is mighty besides Him is humbled; whatever is strong besides Him is weak; whatever possesses is itself possessed; whatever knows besides Him must learn; whatever has power besides Him is at times able and at times helpless. Whoever hears besides Him is deaf to faint sounds, overwhelmed by loud ones, and unaware of those that come from afar. Whoever sees besides Him is blind to hidden colors and subtle bodies. Everything manifest besides Him is hidden, and everything hidden besides Him is manifest.
He did not create what He created to strengthen His sovereignty, nor out of fear of the turns of time, nor to seek help against a hostile rival, an overbearing partner, or a defiant adversary. Rather, all creatures are nurtured under His lordship and are humble, submissive servants. He has not indwelt things, such that it might be said, “He is in them,” nor is He far from them, such that it might be said, “He is separate from them.”
The creation of what He brought into being, and the ordering of its affairs, have not wearied or weakened Him. He has not been rendered incapable by anything He created, nor has any doubt entered into His judgment and decree. Rather, His judgment is firm, His knowledge unshakable, and His command decisive. His servants hope in Him even amid His wrath, and stand in awe of Him even amid His blessings.
Nahj al-Balagha, trans. Ansariyan, p. 138
Attending to the truth that He did not create creatures from His Essence establishes this certain truth: every creature is effaced before His incomparable, indescribable Essence.
God forbid that He should create creatures from His Essence; if He did, His Essence would be diminished by the measure of each creature. And every being that can be diminished is limited. Thus the peerless Essence, which admits of no diminution, has no rival, counterpart, reflection, or shadow; everything before Him is as though nonexistent.
Likewise, His incomparable Essence admits of no increase, for any increase in a being implies a corresponding diminution, equal to what it has absorbed.
Thus creatures cannot add to His Essence, which is beyond our comprehension. He is free of every such description. He is the One; He is the Unique!
Whoever comes to know that he is nothing is thereby effaced, according to the degrees of his understanding and perception—an effacement that has itself come to understand its own effacement.
A gift!!!
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: الله غایه من غیاه و المغیا غیر الغایه توحد بالربوبیه و وصف نفسه بغیر محدودیه فالذاکر الله غیر الله و الله غیر أسمائه و کل شیء وقع علیه اسم شیء سواه فهو مخلوق أ لا ترى إلى قوله العزه لله* العظمه لله و قال و لله الأسماء الحسنى فادعوه بها و قال قل ادعوا الله أو ادعوا الرحمن أیا ما تدعوا فله الأسماء الحسنى فالأسماء مضافه إلیه و هو التوحید الخالص.
التوحید (للصدوق)، ص: 58
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: اسم الله غیر الله و کل شیء وقع علیه اسم شیء فهو مخلوق ما خلا الله فأما ما عبرت الألسن عنه أو عملت الأیدی فیه فهو مخلوق «6» و الله غایه من غایاه و المغیا غیر الغایه و الغایه موصوفه و کل موصوف مصنوع و صانع الأشیاء غیر موصوف بحد مسمى لم یتکون فتعرف کینونته بصنع غیره و لم یتناه إلى غایه إلا کانت غیره لا یذل من فهم هذا الحکم أبدا «1» و هو التوحید الخالص فاعتقدوه و صدقوه و تفهموه بإذن الله عز و جل و من زعم أنه یعرف الله بحجاب أو بصوره أو بمثال فهو مشرک «2» لأن الحجاب و المثال و الصوره غیره «3» و إنما هو واحد موحد فکیف یوحد من زعم أنه عرفه بغیره إنما عرف الله من عرفه بالله «4» فمن لم یعرفه به فلیس یعرفه إنما یعرف غیره و الله خالق الأشیاء لا من شیء یسمى بأسمائه فهو غیر أسمائه و الأسماء غیره و الموصوف غیر الواصف «5» فمن زعم أنه یؤمن بما لا یعرف فهو ضال عن المعرفه لا یدرک مخلوق شیئا إلا بالله و لا تدرک معرفه الله إلا بالله و الله خلو من خلقه و خلقه خلو منه إذا أراد الله شیئا کان کما أراد بأمره من غیر نطق لا ملجأ لعباده مما قضى و لا حجه لهم فیما ارتضى لم یقدروا على عمل و لا معالجه مما أحدث فی أبدانهم المخلوقه إلا بربهم فمن زعم أنه یقوى على عمل لم یرده الله عز و جل فقد زعم أن إرادته تغلب إراده الله «6»- تبارک الله رب العالمین.
التوحید (للصدوق)، ص: 142