Can it be said that knowing God through God is the highest form of knowledge? "I have known You through You, and You have guided me to Yourself." And that a lower level is knowing God through His signs? "So return your gaze; do you see any flaw?" If this is correct, why does Imam Husayn (AS) in this passage of the 'Arafa supplication negate the argument for God through all of creation? "How can one argue for You through something that, in its very existence, is in need of You? Can something other than You have a manifestation that You do not have, so that it becomes the one that manifests You? When were You absent that You should need a proof to point to You?"
Is Knowing God through God the Highest Form of Knowledge?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Knowledge of God is possible only through Him—whether He directly bestows that knowledge or does so through His signs. Knowledge of the signs, too, is possible only through the All-Wise God, for the path to knowing God through His signs is God Himself, who guides us to the signs and from the signs to His own pure threshold. The invitation to reflect on the signs is an invitation to attend the classroom of divine knowledge.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterKnowledge, from beginning to end, is possible only through God, the All-Knowing—and none other. Whether He graciously bestows knowledge directly or through His signs, in either case the path to knowledge is through God alone. Knowledge of the signs, too, is possible only through God, the All-Wise. The way to know God through His signs is also made known by God Himself: He guides us to the signs and, through them, to the threshold of His own holiness.
The Qur’an, the straight path to knowledge, is something we need God’s help to benefit from!
القیامه : 19 ثم إن علینا بیانه
Then its explanation (the Qur’an’s) is Our responsibility!
اللهم عرفنی نفسک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی نفسک لم أعرف نبیک اللهم عرفنی رسولک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی رسولک لم أعرف حجتک اللهم عرفنی حجتک فإنک إن لم تعرفنی حجتک ضللت عن دینی
O God, make Yourself known to me... O God, make Your Messenger known to me... O God, make Your Proof known to me...
God Most High’s call to attend to, reflect on, and reason about His signs is an invitation to take part in a class in divine knowledge. The world is the wise, all-knowing Lord’s teaching display and blackboard!
The luminous words of Imam Husayn علیه السلام acknowledge this indisputable truth: everything in existence is needy and dependent upon the Almighty Lord. Even proofs and arguments depend on Him to have any effect; through Him, proofs and arguments are what they are. Their existence and continuance, and the endurance and efficacy of their effects, all depend on God, the All-Powerful.
God, the All-Knowing, stands between every argument and proof, just as He is the source of light; likewise, their efficacy comes from God. Just as God is the provider, whether He meets a need directly or through blessings, so too He can quench thirst without an intermediary or through water. Yet unless He commands the water to quench thirst, the thirst will not subside. In the same way, He alone is the healer... and He alone bestows knowledge...
Knowledge is one of the beautiful works of divine craftsmanship.
Only God makes known all forms of knowledge and all signs.
عن محمد بن حکیم قال: قلت لأبی عبد الله ع المعرفه من صنع من هی قال من صنع الله لیس للعباد فیها صنع.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج1، ص: 163