In continuation of the answer you expressed so beautifully, could you explain how far one should go in responding with pride to an arrogant person, in light of this hadith?
«التکبر علی المتکبرین هو التواضع بعینه»
“Showing pride toward the arrogant is itself the very essence of humility.”
#Answer 2757
Humility is like a medicine which, when given to the arrogant, aggravates their illness of self-importance. Thus, showing humility can be a kind of injustice to the arrogant person, since it only reinforces their arrogance!
Humility is like healing honey, to be given to those who deserve it!
**The wise practice of humility:**
Humbling yourself before an arrogant person is forbidden.
Humbling yourself before people who misunderstand humility is forbidden, since they may exploit your humility to demean you.
Humility has its limits. If you go beyond them, you may undermine the other person’s self-respect.
The highest form of humility is before the Divine Majesty. The next is before God’s messengers, the Qur’an, and the Ahl al-Bayt. After that comes humility before God’s righteous servants, who have the discernment to appreciate it.
Let us bear in mind that, in the transmitted narration, “showing pride toward the arrogant is itself the very essence of humility” means, first, not humbling yourself before them; next, not undermining their self-respect; and finally, using the deadly poison of pride to combat their arrogance. Only someone with the knowledge and expertise to use this poison can do so.
The degree of pride shown toward an arrogant person should be proportionate to that person’s arrogance. Otherwise, an excessive dose will create problems.
**A few beautiful hadiths**
و من أتى غنیا فتواضع له لغناه ذهب ثلثا دینه
نهج البلاغه (للصبحی صالح)، ص: 508
Whoever visits a wealthy person and humbles himself before him because of his wealth loses two-thirds of his religion.
عن أبی عبد الله ع قال: إن الله عز و جل فوض إلى المؤمن أموره کلها و لم یفوض إلیه أن یکون ذلیلا «1» أ ما تسمع قول الله عز و جل یقول- و لله العزه و لرسوله و للمؤمنین «2» فالمؤمن یکون عزیزا و لا یکون ذلیلا ثم قال إن المؤمن أعز من الجبل إن الجبل یستقل منه بالمعاول و المؤمن لا یستقل «3» من دینه شیء.
الکافی (ط - الإسلامیه)، ج5، ص: 63
Imam Sadiq (peace be upon him) said: God, Mighty and Majestic, has entrusted all of the believer’s affairs to him, but has not permitted him to be abased. Have you not heard God, Mighty and Majestic, say:
«و لله العزه و لرسوله و للمؤمنین»
“Glory belongs to God, His Messenger, and the believers.” Thus, the believer is dignified and is not to be abased. He then said: “The believer is mightier than a mountain. Pieces can be hewn from a mountain with pickaxes, but nothing can be taken from the believer’s faith.”