If someone denies that the attributes belong to the Essence of the Real, but is mistaken in this belief, are they counted among the polytheists?
Is One Who Denies the Divine Attributes a Polytheist?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
If someone denies that attributes belong to the Essence of the Real, with the aim of affirming God’s oneness and out of the utmost sincerity, they are not counted among the polytheists. Rather, their affirmation of divine unity is all the more uncompromising. By contrast, someone who holds that the attributes are identical with the Essence first affirms the attributes and then identifies them with the Essence of the Real.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAnyone who holds that the attributes of the Real are identical with the Essence of the Real is, in effect, seeking to enter into pure tawhid by casting down the staff of shirk. That is, at first they lean on the staff of shirk, and then make it conform to the Essence of the Real. But:
Anyone who denies every attribute of the Essence of the Real relies on no staff whatsoever to affirm the Real’s oneness; they believe in nothing but unity. By contrast, anyone who holds that the attributes are identical with the Essence first affirms the attributes alongside the Essence of the Real, then, rather than denying them, makes them identical with the Essence.
Thus,
Whoever, in the realm of perfect sincerity, denies the attributes of the Divine Essence in fact arrives at affirmation, confession and belief in tawhid through tawhid itself. In truth, this group’s tawhid is of a higher intensity.