What is your view on classifying the divine attributes as attributes of essence and attributes of action?
What Is Your View on Dividing the Divine Attributes into Attributes of Essence and Attributes of Action?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
No attribute manifests in the world of existence except through the divine will to create. Thus, the attributes are manifested only through the creation of creatures, and all the attributes are attributes of His action. If we accept attributes of essence, we must ask through which attribute of essence His acts are manifested—a question that ultimately leads back to the attributes of action.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterNo attribute comes into manifestation in the universe unless He wills to create. Before the creation of creatures, nothing can be conceived of the Divine Essence apart from Its unique Essence; that is, no attribute can be conceived of in relation to His peerless Essence. Attributes, then, are disclosed only through the creation of creatures. Everything that exists is therefore an attribute of His action!
Even if we accept a distinction between essential attributes and attributes of action, we must answer this question: through which essential attribute do the Lord’s acts manifest themselves? Suppose they manifest through God’s attribute of knowledge. We must then ask whether this manifestation is of the same order as creation or not. If it is of the same order as creation, then Allah has brought it forth through His attribute of creating—yet creating is regarded as one of the Lord’s attributes of action.
If it is not of the same order as creation, then what is its order? If we say it is of the order of His knowing, then what has been manifested is what He knows, like a created thing. In this case, too, the manifestation of what is known gives meaning to the knowing of the All-Knowing through the disclosure of the attribute of knowledge. Here, too, knowledge must be considered one of the divine attributes of action.