Is Paradise reserved only for those who are companions of God's Proofs? And is the reason for punishment in Hell separation from God's Proofs?
Is Paradise Reserved Only for the Companions of God’s Proofs, and Is the Punishment of Hell Separation from Them?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Those who deny the wilaya and harbor hatred toward God's Proofs will abide eternally in Hell and will not catch even the scent of Paradise. Paradise has various levels and degrees, and the condition for closeness and nearness to God's Proofs is harmony of heart, tongue, and action in loving and showing affection toward them. The people of Paradise look upon the dwellings of the Shi'a just as a person gazes at the stars of the sky.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterWhoever denies the authority of the Divine Proofs and harbours enmity toward them will remain forever in Hell and will never even smell the fragrance of Paradise.
The believers who will enter Paradise are not all necessarily destined to be in the company of the Divine Proofs. The condition for companionship, closeness and neighbourly proximity to the Divine Proofs is harmony and unity of “heart, tongue and action” in love and devotion to them.
Paradise has different levels, and its inhabitants occupy different ranks.
أن أمیر المؤمنین علیه السلام: .... من أحبنا بقلبه و أعاننا بلسانه و قاتل معنا أعداءنا بیده فهو معنا فی الجنه فی درجتنا و من أحبنا بقلبه و أعاننا بلسانه و لم یقاتل معنا أعداءنا فهو أسفل من ذلک بدرجتین و من أحبنا بقلبه و لم یعنا بلسانه و لا بیده فهو فی الجنه و من أبغضنا بقلبه و أعان علینا بلسانه و یده فهو مع عدونا فی النار و من أبغضنا بقلبه و أعان علینا بلسانه فهو فی النار «2» و من أبغضنا بقلبه و لم یعن علینا بلسانه و لا بیده فهو فی النار إن أهل الجنه لینظرون إلى منازل شیعتنا کما ینظر الإنسان إلى الکواکب فی السماء...
الخصال، ج2، ص: 629
Whoever loves us in his heart, supports us with his tongue, and fights our enemies alongside us with his hand will be with us in Paradise, at our rank. Whoever loves us in his heart and supports us with his tongue but does not fight our enemies alongside us will be two degrees below that. Whoever loves us in his heart but supports us neither with his tongue nor with his hand will still be in Paradise. Whoever hates us in his heart and supports those who oppose us with his tongue and hand will be with our enemy in the Fire. Whoever hates us in his heart and supports those who oppose us with his tongue will be in the Fire. And whoever hates us in his heart but does not oppose us with either his tongue or his hand will also be in the Fire. Indeed, the people of Paradise will look upon the dwellings of our followers just as a person looks upon the stars in the sky...
al-Khisal, vol. 2, p. 629
عن الحسن بن علی ع أنه قال من أحبنا بقلبه و نصرنا بیده و لسانه فهو معنا فی الغرفه التی نحن فیها و من أحبنا بقلبه و نصرنا بلسانه فهو دون ذلک بدرجه و من أحبنا بقلبه و کف بیده و لسانه فهو فی الجنه
الأمالی (للمفید)، النص، ص: 34
ʿAmr ibn Abi al-Miqdam relates from his father that Imam Hasan al-Mujtaba (AS) said: Whoever loves us in his heart and supports us with his hand and tongue will be with us on the Day of Resurrection in the chamber where we are. Whoever loves us in his heart and supports us with his tongue will be one degree below that. And whoever loves us in his heart but refrains from supporting us with his hand and tongue will also be in Paradise.
al-Amali (by al-Mufid), text, p. 34