Peace be upon you, esteemed teacher. May God grant you strength. Is there anything wrong with performing qama-zani in public, purely out of love for Imam Husayn (AS)? Please explain the reasons. Thank you.
Is Public Qama-zani Out of Love for Imam Husayn (AS) Problematic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
Public qama-zani out of love for Imam Husayn (AS) is problematic because it is not accepted by society and fosters negative perceptions of religion. The conduct of the Infallibles should guide mourning rituals, and practices that drive people away from the Ahl al-Bayt (AS) are not endorsed.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterA lover of Imam حسین علیه السلام follows the path of زین العابدین علیه السلام; he is no tyrant in the arena of mourning for him.
Every act has a particular intention. Public mourning not only gives expression to grief and anguish over the tragedy; it also serves to convey a message. Our manner of mourning should further the exalted aims of حضرت سید الشهدا علیه السلام. Otherwise, it will become a barrier, an obstacle, a veil obscuring the purposes he intended. It is plain to all that people today do not accept the practice of striking one’s head with a blade. They react against it and reproach those who do it; some may even form a negative view of the mourners, criticize the very roots of this faith, and turn away from it. If someone’s act turns even one person away from the path of guidance toward اهل بیت علیهم السلام, it is as though he has led all humanity astray.
We should therefore take the conduct and practice of the Infallibles علیهم السلام as our model in mourning. Had they approved this practice, they would surely have been the first to undertake it; yet no report of it has come down from their sacred presence.
A lover of Imam حسین علیه السلام is one who strives to resemble his master and becomes renowned throughout the world for piety, righteous deeds, and abstaining from sin. A lover of Imam حسین علیه السلام is one who works to reveal his master’s radiant face to all the world—not one whose actions keep those enamored of him from taking flight around the candle of his being.