**Summarized question**
Given that one of the conditions of sincere repentance is not returning to sin, is repentance that does not last forever of any benefit?
**Full question**
True repentance is repentance without a return to sin. Yet God says in the Qur’an, “O My servants who have sinned, do not despair of My mercy” (Qur’an 39:53). Then, in verse 55 of Sūrat al-Aʿrāf, God says that He does not love those who transgress the limits. This shows how much we should fear sin.
For example, God forbid, I commit a sin—lying, backbiting, and so on, about which there are many warnings—and at night I repent and feel remorse. Does this repentance have any value if, whenever I become heedless, I commit a grave sin, only to start all over again the next day?
After all, no human being is infallible except the Imams (peace be upon them). But perhaps someone takes steps to avoid disobedience and, under the circumstances, is unable to do so.
There is also a narration in which the Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him and his family) said:
التائب من الذنب کمن لا ذنب له و المستغفر من الذنب و هو مقیم علیه کالمستهزئ بربه و من آذى مسلما کان علیه من الذنوب مثل منابت النخل؛
“One who repents of a sin is like one who has not sinned. But one who seeks forgiveness for a sin while continuing to commit it is like one who mocks his Lord. And whoever harms a Muslim bears as many sins as there are palm trees.”
*Nahj al-Faṣāḥah*
Ethics scholars say that if we want to know whether our repentance has been accepted and our sin forgiven, we should have abandoned that sin forever—that is, our repentance has been accepted. Is that right? Of course, we are not in a position to judge God.
Also, a person may refrain from a sin for a while, then commit it again after a long time, whether deliberately or otherwise. Is that, too, considered mocking God?