Peace be upon you. I hope you are well. I have a question: Is this report authentic or not?
The Prophet صلى الله علیه و آله said: “There are four kinds of people whose backbiting is not considered backbiting: someone who openly commits sins; a deceitful leader who neither thanks you when you do good nor forgives you when you do wrong; people who jokingly insult one another’s mothers; and someone who separates himself from the Muslim community, finds fault with my ummah, and draws his sword against them.”
Is the Hadith About Four Categories of People Whose Backbiting Is Permissible Authentic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
A report from the Prophet (PBUH) is said to permit backbiting about four categories of people: someone who openly sins, a deceitful leader, people who jokingly insult one another’s mothers, and someone who separates himself from the Muslim community and finds fault with the ummah. This concession applies only for the purpose of religious admonition and informing the public, and must be made with the intention of drawing closer to God—not for disparagement or amusement.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterOf course, this kind of backbiting is permitted not for entertainment, disparagement, and the like, but solely for the purpose of religious admonition and informing public opinion about the formation of ties and relationships, and similar matters. It must be done with the intention of seeking closeness to God, not out of a zeal for backbiting!
قال رسول الله ص أربعه لیس غیبتهم غیبه الفاسق المعلن بفسقه و الإمام الکذاب إن أحسنت لم یشکر و إن أسأت لم یغفر و المتفکهون بالأمهات و الخارج من الجماعه الطاعن على أمتی الشاهر علیها بسیفه
النوادر (للراوندی)، ص: 19