Is the following hadith considered reliable in terms of its chain of transmission? If its chain is not reliable, is its meaning nevertheless true? Imam al-Sadiq (AS) said: “No one from us, the Ahl al-Bayt, rises before our Qa’im (AJ) to remove an injustice or reclaim a right without being afflicted by calamity and hardship. His uprising only increases the suffering of us and our followers.”
Wasāʾil al-Shīʿa, vol. 8, p. 188
Is the Hadith “No One from Us, the Ahl al-Bayt, Rises Before the Qa’im (AJ) Without Being Afflicted by Calamity” Authentic?
The essence and first answer at a glance (60-word summary)
This hadith refers to uprisings that take place before the uprising of the Qa’im (AJ), under the claim of raising the banner of the divinely appointed successor. An uprising without the permission of the infallible Imam brings calamity and hardship, increasing the suffering of the Ahl al-Bayt and their followers. Imam Husayn’s (AS) statement on the need to rise against oppressors—even though he himself suffered calamity as a result of his uprising—supports this point.
Answer by Master Ali Saei (Abdullah Meshkat)
Teacher and researcher in the intellectual tradition of wisdom and the Ahl al-Bayt | Soroush Bamdadān Cultural CenterAs noted in entry 974, the hadith refers to an uprising that claims to raise the banner of the divine caliphate before the uprising of Imam al-Qa'im علیه السلام.
The words of Imam حسین علیه السلام, to shed light on the discussion above:
من الحسین بن علی إلى سلیمان بن صرد و المسیب بن نجبه و رفاعه بن شداد و عبد الله بن وال و جماعه المؤمنین أما بعد فقد علمتم أن رسول الله ص قد قال فی حیاته من رأى سلطانا جائرا مستحلا لحرم الله ناکثا لعهد الله مخالفا لسنه رسول الله یعمل فی عباد الله بالإثم و العدوان ثم لم یغیر بقول و لا فعل کان حقیقا على الله أن یدخله مدخله و قد علمتم أن هؤلاء القوم قد لزموا طاعه الشیطان و تولوا عن طاعه الرحمن و أظهروا الفساد و عطلوا الحدود و استأثروا بالفیء و أحلوا حرام الله و حرموا حلاله و إنی أحق بهذا الأمر لقرابتی من رسول الله ص و قد أتتنی کتبکم و قدمت علی رسلکم ببیعتکم أنکم لا تسلمونی و لا تخذلونی فإن وفیتم لی ببیعتکم فقد أصبتم حظکم و رشدکم و نفسی مع أنفسکم و أهلی و ولدی مع أهالیکم و أولادکم فلکم بی أسوه و إن لم تفعلوا و نقضتم عهودکم و خلعتم بیعتکم فلعمری ما هی منکم بنکر لقد فعلتموها بأبی و أخی و ابن عمی و المغرور من اغتر بکم فحظکم أخطأتم و نصیبکم ضیعتم- فمن نکث فإنما ینکث على نفسه و سیغنی الله عنکم و السلام.
بحار الأنوار (ط - بیروت)، ج44، ص: 382
O people! The Messenger of God (PBUH) said: “Whoever sees an unjust ruler who treats what God has forbidden as lawful, breaks God’s covenant, opposes the practice of the Messenger of God, and acts among God’s servants with sin and aggression, yet does not oppose him in word or deed, deserves for God to consign him to the same place as that ruler.”
Now, O people! This group—the Umayyads—have bound themselves to obey Satan and turned away from obedience to the All-Merciful. They have spread corruption and suspended the divinely prescribed penalties. They have claimed the public treasury for themselves, declaring what God has forbidden lawful and what He has permitted forbidden. And I, as the grandson of the Messenger of God, am more entitled than anyone to rise up and change this state of affairs.